Art For Art’s Sake

Donald Read is the author of ‘Art for Art’s Sake’, being the next essay in The Folio Society’s history of Victorian England.

Read covers painting, drawing, design, architecture, and literature in their numerous forms from the perspective of their purposes and adherents. Walter Pater’s Aestheticism as a term came into vogue under the slogan of ‘art for art’s sake’, in offering itself as a substitute both for belief in political progress and for religious expectation, and as a retreat from life. Ruskin, on the other hand, wanted art and literature to be part of life.

“[James McNeill] Whistler scorned narrative painting and insisted that it was not the subject that was most important – not even his own mother, of whom he painted a notable portrait – but the arrangement of forms, colours, light and shade.”

“[William] Morris denounced ‘art for art’s sake’ as ‘a piece of slang that does not mean the harmless thing its seems to mean….An art cultivated professedly by a few, and for a few, who would consider it necessary – a duty, if they could admit duties – to despise the common herd…” “From the early 1860s Morris worked with great originality inside his ‘firm’ of fellow craftsmen in the making of fabrics, wallpapers, glass, furniture, and the like…… `….. [he] helped to inspire the Arts and Crafts movement of the 1880s and 1890s…. The sinuous curves of art nouveau, based on leaf patterns, and other natural, forms, represented a distinctive and exciting style of design exclusive to the decade.”

“In architecture Morris’s ideas were first expressed through the Red House at Bexleyheath, completed in 1860 with Philip Webb as architect.”

Sargent and Sickert. displayed some Impressionist skill in the handling of light. “Sickert’s work remained fresher especially in his moving evocations of music-hall interiors, which conveyed not detail but a sense of life and action.”

“By the late 1880s ‘aestheticism’ was changing into ‘decadence…'” “yet the decadents were themselves in reaction against the admiration of beauty. They professed to prefer pessimism to optimism, the decayed to the living, the abnormal to the normal…….A sense of corruption certainly pervaded the sickly but powerful drawings of Aubrey Beardsley…..”

“The Yellow Book, which started in 1894 with a lurid cover drawn by Beardsley was regarded by the public at large as the very epitome of decadence.”

[Rudyard] “Kipling came to mean different things to different people…” From the time of the raj, voices of imperial achievement, confidence, responsibility and concern.

“During the 1880s fiction overtook theology as the largest category among new books and new editions published each year.” The three volume novel was losing ground to the single tome. The moral usefulness of fiction was less in doubt and content became quite daring. “Hardy’s Tess of the d’Urbervilles (1891) was the first major English novel to allow a seduced woman to appear as an unqualified heroine…” Nevertheless ‘Lady Chatterley’s Lover’ was six decades away. https://derrickjknight.com/2022/09/17/a-knights-tale-38-1-wives-and-servants/

A “…shift towards realism in play writing owed much to ,the example of Ibsen….. ruthless in his revelations of social hypocrisy.,,,,”

Gilbert and Sullivan’s light operas still engage loyal followers today, “long after Sullivan’s more pretentious compositions have been forgotten. Indeed, Jackie’s cousin Pat O’Connell directed the whole of the G & S canon for the Godalming Operatic Society.

Newspapers and magazines of varying intellectual standards are discussed, and lead to the importance of education for all classes – brains as well as hands needed to be developed. “As the new Board Schools spread over England they were taken as examples of the progress of the age.”

Class again came into consideration when looking at the importance of sport, from football to hunting, shooting, and golf/

______________

This evening’s dinner will consist of Jackie’s chicken jalfrezi, pilau rice, chicken samosas and parathas with which she will drink Franziskaner Weissbier and I will drink Estevez Reserva Pinot Noir 2025,

The Alice Lisle

Alice, Lady Lisle (September 1617 – 2 September 1685), was a daughter of Sir White Beconshaw of Moyles Court at Ellingham in Hampshire and his wife Edith Bond, daughter and co-heiress of William Bond of Blackmanston in Steeple, Dorset. Alice became the second wife of John Lisle (1610 – 11 August 1664), and bore him seven children. (Extracts from Wikipedia)

After the battle of Sedgemoor in 1685, Alice sheltered two of Monmouth’s defeated supporters overnight at her home in Moyles Court. They were arrested in the morning and she and they were tried as traitors. She had the further misfortune to be tried before the infamous Judge Jeffreys at the opening of the Bloody Assizes in Winchester. Jeffreys had no pretence at impartiality and bullied the jury into a guilty verdict after only fifteen minutes of deliberation.

Jackie photographed the account of the trial on the wall of the pub

and a description of ‘The Hanging Judge’. You may need to enlarge these with a click on each.

Interestingly, Lady Lisle’s home, Moyles Court, which lies across the road from the pub, is now a children’s boarding school, and the building that was the village school, is renamed in her honour as this pub. Another photograph on the wall reproduced by Jackie is of Elsie

Dean and Joan Clarke on the last day before Rockford School closed in 1941. This was an earlier incarnation of what became the hostelry.

On the narrow, winding Gorley Road to our destination we were somewhat hampered by a delivery clearly heading for the same establishment.

Jackie was out of the car quick enough to catch the load of London

Pride vanishing beside the front of the building and to make various other pictures of the frontage with its colourful hanging baskets.

Somewhat slower than Mrs Knight I photographed her entering the building.

Here are my pictures of the inside;

and more of Jackie’s.

She also pictured The History of the Alice Lisle;

Alice’s portrait;

Fused glass enamelled pictures for sale;

a New Forest Southern Railway poster;

and our good quality meals which like all these pictures bear titles in the gallery accessed by clicking on any one image in each.

Outside she found dogs were well catered for water, and

there was a view from the garden of Blashford lakes, with a warning of deep water deterring further exploration.

This evening scrambled egg on toast, with which Jackie drank Zesty white wine and I drank more of the merlot, sufficed for our dinner.

Ran’s Wood

Today I read ‘Art for Art’s Sake by Donald Read which I will probably review in a couple of days.

Later on this warm, overcast, and humid afternoon we took a drive to

Ran’s Wood where we met the only livestock, in the form of ponies, we had seen.

This evening we dined on Jackie’s chicken Jalfrezi, special fried rice, vegetable samosas and parathas with which she drank more of the white wine and I drank more of the merlot.

W.XV Rugby And Culling

This afternoon I watched a recording of yesterday’s W.XV Global rugby Test match between Wales and U.S.A.

Afterwards I culled from my iPhotos file all pictures included in

and all but one of those in

This evening we dined on cottage pie; a melange of fried potatoes. leeks, and mushrooms; carrots, cauliflower, and Brussels sprouts, with which Jackie drank Franziskaner Weissbier and I drank Pierre Jaurant Merlot 2024.

As October Beckons

Jackie has been concentrating on two main garden projects over the last few days as well as her normal weeding and watering. Yesterday she carried her camera with her, giving me plenty of blogging to do today.

Our alley beside North Breeze has become inaccessible and acts as a wind channel when gusts are tearing through the Needles in a direct line as the crow flies with it.

The first picture in this gallery shows the mess that Jackie had to clear before being able to rake the gravel and eventually empty the channel.

Among the extraneous material were tangled tendrils of convolvulus roots invaded from next door. Most of Jackie’s tulip bulbs were eaten this year. The culprit, presumably a squirrel, had heaped a stash of outer skins along with hazel nut husks among other refuse here.

Jackie took time to fill a trug with tomatoes, some of which we enjoyed for lunch. There are as many still on the vines.

The Generous Gardener rose, despite bearing many hips, also bears buds; that is unusual but not as much as

a foxglove bearing buds at this time of year.

Jackie’s other major task has been resetting the stone wall around the Oval Bed, sieving and levelling the gravel in the path. She needed to lift some of the stones, and remove the mingled soil, leaving a drop from the brick section of the path. She is still in the process of returning the clean gravel and distributing the soil around the flower beds.

As she has been picking up broken plants after the storms she has grown cuttings which are now in the greenhouse;

others await further planting on various tables.

The wren’s nest is still where they left it.

Other footpaths and stepping stones divide beds like The Weeping Birch and the West ones.

Owls are on constant watch throughout the plot.

Jackie photographed som of her favourite plants and scenes.

Here are a few more.

One splendid azalea fell foul of honey fungus. Its stem now forms a lantern tree all the blooms of which are solar powered to light up the night.

This afternoon I watched the W.XV Global rugby international between England and New Zealand

Our dinner this evening consisted of maple pork fillets, boiled potatoes, cauliflower, cabbage, green and runner beans, and Brussels sprouts with which Jackie drank Franziskaner Weissbier and I finished the Fleurie.

‘Prudes On The Prowl’:The View From The Empire Promenade

John Stokes is the author of this next essay in the Folio Society ‘Victorian England’ history.

He presents a picture of the controversial London music halls of the nineties. “At the start of the decade the halls had undergone a process of rapid expansion as the shabby, suburban establishments, with their ‘chairmen’, their rough and ready ‘turns’ and their local clientele were challenged by the big West End theatres, the most

celebrated being the two in Leicester Square: the Alhambra (rebuilt in 1882) and the Empire (a music hall since 1887). These offered ‘two shows a night’ variety bills, lavish dance spectacles and – less widely advertised – attractive venues for prostitutes…..”

Led by The Daily Telegraph, written arguments raged for and against. On the one hand we had ‘Englishman’ who thought cleaning up the halls would be retrogressive and drive the women onto the streets; on the other the alleged ‘Prudes’ led by the philanthropic Mrs Chant, who wished to improve their lot. “She was particularly concerned about the Promenades, those areas of the theatre open to the public at large and affording distant views of the stage where, for an admission price of five shillings, people could relax during the shows and take refreshments. Along the Empire Promenade she had seen ‘young women….more or less painted, and gorgeously dressed, who ‘accosted young gentlemen; while on the stage itself, ballets were being performed whose ‘chief object appeared…… to be to show the limbs of the female performers.’

Another contentious method of revealing even more was ‘Living Pictures’, where tableaux were created by unmoving models playing the parts of paintings or other artworks. It is of course culturally acceptable to show all if it is art, but not if it isn’t.

“In a music hall the audience is part of the performance” was the view of the theatre critic, Arthur Symons.

Stokes discusses different forms of entertainment such as dance in a broader sense, including ballet, cancan, and burlesque, describing the genuine art that goes into it and the long years of training.

He discusses the painters who record the performances in the halls,

notably Walter Sickert, Whistler,

and the less gifted Joseph Pennell.

Aubrey Beardsley also gets a mention.

All the illustrations can be enlarged by clicking on any one in each gallery.

This afternoon I watched a recording of the W.XV Global Women’s rugby match between England and Australia.

Our dinner this evening consisted of oven battered haddock and French fries with peas, sweetcorn, and onion rings with which Jackie drank Winemakers Zesty white wine and I drank more of the Fleurie.

Keeping Pictures

Today I read ‘Prudes on the Prowl’: The view from the Empire Promenade, which I hope to review tomorrow.

Later I deleted from my iPhotos file all but one of the pictures featured in

and none of those from

We are now about to dine on cottage pie, carrots, cauliflower and Brussels sprouts with which Jackie will drink Juicy rosé and I will drink Louis Jadot Poncereau Fleurie 2022.

Memories For Posterity 4

Today I published https://derrickjknight.com/2026/09/23/the-victorian-ethos-before-and-after-victoria-and-late-victorian-women/

This afternoon Elizabeth came over to work on our joint book ‘The memories between us’.

We produced drafts of the the next four pages, through the process of my sister sending material to Chatgpt and negotiating with that AI medium for alterations and additions to save for further alterations as we move along.

Elizabeth stayed for dinner which consisted of cottage pie, cauliflower, carrots, and Brussels sprouts, followed by lemon meringue pie, with which I finished the Pinot Noir, Jackie drank more of the rosé, and my sister drank water.

Published
Categorised as Books

The Victorian Ethos: Before And After Victoria; And Late Victorian Women

This post covers the next two consecutive essays in The Folio Society’s ‘Victorian England’ because they seem to be clearly related. Gertrude Himmelfarb, in the first, suggests that the period is “too long, the tempo of change too rapid, the cast of characters too motley to permit of generalisation….” as ‘Victorianism’

“Some of the most eminent Victorian worthies were also the most notorious flouters of convention: John Stuart Mill, who courted Mrs Taylor for almost twenty years with her husband hovering in the background; George Eliot, [the male pseudonym of the female writer] who lived with G. H. Lewes for more than twenty years quite as if his wife did not exist…….And there were those who managed to offend propriety in reverse: Carlyle and Ruskin, for example, whose desire for marriage was so much more compelling than their desire for sexual relations that they lived in permanent celibacy with their wives……” Nevertheless “Ethics, religion, and philosophy, changing in themselves and shifting in relation to each other, merged to constitute a unique ethos.”

Both writers consider the class differences of the people in their subjects and how these impact on their lives. Pat Thane, the second, in focussing on women, speaks of the general improvement of their health, living conditions, and consequent length of life over the period of two thirds of a century. My extracts tend to be general but Professor Thane does tell of the effects of different disparities in class.

“Whatever the precise overall picture, the period saw changes of dramatic importance concerning female health. Above all, more women felt, and were, able to control not only the number of their pregnancies and the size of their families but could feel, as a result, a potential for control over their lives that was historically unprecedented.” Birth control was becoming an option. “As women gave birth to fewer babies and ceased child-bearing at younger ages the survival chances of both infants and mothers were enhanced.”

Annie Besant was an ardent proponent of birth control and socialism.

Although it remained difficult, before this time it had been impossible for a woman to obtain a divorce in our male dominated society. “Gradually, it seems, in complex ways still incompletely explored, divorce court judges were moving towards a conception of marriage as a contract embodying reciprocal rights and obligations between husband and wife which both were expected to observe, rather than as a relationship of patriarchal domination and dependence.”

The importance of motherhood was pivotal. “….there was an enhanced public emphasis upon motherhood and the importance of stable family life at a time when more women than before were challenging women’s expected role and the family faced an unprecedented level of criticism.” Women were questioning whether they even wanted to marry or manage a family.

“There is no reason to doubt that the largest single female paid occupation was domestic service.” “Most servants were the sole general servant in a not very wealthy household, hence the harshness of their working lives…..” “However, a significant proportion of middle-class households were well enough off for everyday comfort, but could not afford to keep their daughters in idleness, perhaps indefinitely if they did not marry. This material reality encouraged many middle-class men to support improved secondary education for girls, as a path towards a respectable career, probably in teaching. Fewer of them showed enthusiasm for female higher education, which threatened to tempt women to compete in the masculine professions. This period saw the unprecedented expansion of serious education for females at private secondary, teacher-training and university levels….”

Being a wife at home managing the family and its income was often regarded as unpaid drudgery; and “In practice a very high proportion of working-class households depended upon earnings from the wife at some point in their life cycle.”

The more wealthy women could choose whether they took paid employment or engaged in ‘lady bountiful’ charitable work.

A Short Drive East

Late this afternoon we took a drive via Church Lane, Pilley outward,

and returning via South Baddesley Road.

At East End a group of ponies on our left were cropping the verge. The head appearing to the left of the second picture butted the foal to the right out of her way. Jackie watched those to our right through her window. Their verge was not as smooth as the grass on the other side.

At Christmastime the artificial tree against this house is decorated according to the season. For the rest of the year anything goes.

This evening we dined on roast chicken, boiled potatoes, Brussels sprouts, Yorkshire pudding, carrots, cauliflower and meaty gravy, accompanied by the same beverages as yesterday.