This lengthy novel by Donna Tartt, linking past and present is both a study of grief and a murder mystery in the depths of Mississippi, accompanied by a desire for revenge.
At the end of the book the author acknowledges the invaluable help of a long list of people who must surely have provided her with detailed information about numerous activities; the thorough descriptive prose is undoubtedly her own.
She likes alliteration, simile, and metaphor, often slipping in brief examples of one sentence gems. “…across her plate, and piled it up in unappetising heaps…”. ” …books, curio cabinets and bric-a-brac….” “…her white head ruffled like a peony…” “he practised a golf swing with an invisible club.” “The moon shone in a puddle in the sidewalk.” “A tic fluttered in his eyelid.” “Cobwebs of lassitude drifted over her.”. The unfortunate “For a mongoloid he had very long eyelashes” is an outdated, inaccurate, term which grates.
Both her long, flowing sentences and her shorter, conversational ones, take us smoothly through the pages as she engages all senses. “Harriet practically felt the smoke rising off her as if she was a pile of dry wood chips smoldering in a beam of light.” “The night air was warm, and the moth-pale gardenia blossom had a rich, warm, boozy smell. How could you ever be perfectly sure when you were dreaming and when you are awake?….” Thoughts and feelings are described in depth.
Her action sequences are particularly vivid and often visceral and painful to read. Her grasp of grammar and parts of speech is sound; she has full command of dialogue and local accents.
Her characterisation displays deep complex knowledge of the elements that contribute to the nature of her protagonists.
“Allison was now sixteen. A mousy little girl who bruised and sunburned easily and cried at nearly everything, she had grown up, unexpectedly , to be the pretty one; long legs, fawn-red hair, liquid, fawn-brown eyes. All her grace was in her vagueness. Her voice was soft, her manner languid, her features blurred and dreamy; and to her grandmother Edie – who prized sparkle and high colour – she was something of a disappointment. Allison’s bloom was delicate and artless, like the flowering grass in June, consisting wholly of a youthful freshness that (no one knew better than Edie) ….. and the boys in her class had started to call her on the telephone….”
“Danny was fairly sure that his grandmother did not love cooking for her boys quite so much as she said she did. She was a tiny, emaciated, leather-brown creature, so decrepit that she looked closer to a hundred than her real age – somewhere around sixty. Born to a Cajun-French father and a mother who was a full-blood Chickasaw, in a sharecropper’s shack with a dirt floor and no plumbing (privations on which she daily refreshed her grandsons, Gum had been married, at thirteen, to a fur trapper twenty-five years her senior. It was hard to imagine what she’d looked like in those days – in her hardscrabble youth there had bee no money for foolishness like cameras and pictures….”
Tartt understands the part played by imagination, and how it can alter reality.
“One of the big guns had a bayonet attachment, which was interesting, but her favourite was the Winchester with the telescopic scope. She switched off the overhead light and propped the barrel on the sill of the living room window and looked down the scope with narrowed eyes – at parked cars, pavement sparkling under the high lamps and sprinklers hissing on lush empty lawns. The fort was under attack; she was guarding her post and all their lives depended on it.”
Terrain and the nature of buildings affects those who live there. We see building being erected on mud flats. The now demolished ancestral home is called “Tribulation”.
An early sudden death has ripped the heart and soul from the principal family, and, in my view, from this book, largely devoid of humour.
The nature of grief is very well analysed. In particular we are shown how its obsessive focus can leave those still living without adequate cere or consideration. The absence of those departing suddenly demonstrates who and what has been lost, and, particularly insightful, is showing that we can also grieve what we have never had; and the important necessity of saying goodbye.
” “Come back to me, you scamp!””… she called……. But though he usually liked having his picture made, sometimes he was skittish about it – came out a red-headed blur, sharp elbows and kneecaps scrambling to get away….and then, on impulse, she’d raised the camera and snapped it at him anyway. It was the last picture they had of him. Out of focus. Flat expanse of green cut at a slight diagonal, with a white rail and the heaving gloss of a gardenia bush sharp in the foreground at the edge of the porch…….”
Such caring as is provided is given by grandmothers and a group of great aunts.
We have whole chapters focussing on the dark side of life, sometimes making me wonder where this was all going. I had no desire to post extracts, although they do exemplify all I have said above.
Finally, do we know who the murderer was?
This is a work to be admired and respected, but not loved by me.
This evening we dined on chicken Kiev, French fries, and onion rings, with the same wines as yesterday.