When reviewing fiction I tend to avoid details which will act as spoilers, yet include quotations which don’t give the game away. With history I have also to tell the story, so far without extracts particularly in this Folio Society series, because the others have lacked the literary
quality of G. R. Elton’s prose which makes this book so readable. Here, I aim to do both.
“When victory was won at Bosworth, Lord Stanley, whose timely desertion of Richard III had made Henry’s triumph possible, picked up the crown and put it on the victor’s head; according to the chronicler, people rejoiced and clapped their hands and cried, ‘King Henry, King Henry’. But while this acclamation must have been pleasant to his ears, it did not make the gold circlet sit any more securely on his head. Henry VII’s first task was to convince the country and the world that he really was king…..”
“Henry’s own claim to the crown was far from straightforward. Fifteenth-century England knew no proper law of succession….Legitimacy – the doctrine that the crown can descend only to one man at any given time and that this succession is determined by primogeniture – was the centre of the Yorkist position….but the strict theory of legitimacy was still the property of a party, and the Lancastrians had never subscribed to it.”
“The reign was never quite free from the fact or threat of conspiracy, and for several years Henry VII had to defend his throne against the kind of enterprise which had secured it to him in the first place.”
In particular, plots involving Lambert Simnel and Perkin Warbeck were to follow. “In the year 1491, a young man of seventeen, servant to a Breton merchant, was walking and down the streets of Cork, displaying on his person the silk clothes in which his master traded. His bearing and splendour made a great impression on the rather backward townsfolk, unsettled as they already were by tales of the Plantagenet princes escaping hither and thither. They told the young man that he was the earl of Warwick, and when he denied this they obligingly changed him into a bastard of Richard III…… His real name was Perkin Warbeck.” writes Elton, disbelieving the story which is further explored in
“Scotland, by dint of its ancient alliance with France had managed to remain a very painful thorn in England’s side…….Compared with

Scotland, harassed by perpetual feuds, gang warfare, murders, and domestic upsets, even the England of the Wars of the Roses was almost a law-abiding and peaceful state ….”. “The border from Berwick to Carlisle was practically never at peace as raiding parties crossed from either side, to kill, rob and burn on the other.”
Henry VII secured the dynasty and restored government.
“The truth is that Tudor kingship was strong in itself. To listen to some historians, one might think that that large scale rebellion is the kind of thing men devise over breakfast and carry out between lunch and dinner. By being king, and by exploiting the great inherent strength of that office, Henry VII put himself into a position of such power that disagreement had to reach a very considerable pitch before it would translate itself into resistance.”
In taking care of revenue the king husbanded “his resources in a sensible manner by careful management and controlled spending.”
“Until the creation of a regular police force in the nineteenth century, England remained a country of ready violence. Every dispute turned easily to bloodshed; in the Tudor age, men were far too quick to draw daggers, wield clubs, break heads and raise riots.” The king’s councillors at Westminster for the most serious offences and the local common law jurors remained the bodies for enforcing law.
“In the reign of the first Tudor, parliament was still an occasional rather than a permanent part of government which was in the hands of the king and his courts – institutions of which parliament, though the most solemn, was the least frequent and in practice therefore the least important.”
“In the reign of Henry VII the Church enjoyed a kind of medieval Indian summer. Relations with the lay power – the king – were excellent…. the problem of the relations of Church and state never came up and remained unsolved…..”
“The reign of Henry VIII opened in a blaze of glory…. In his young days, Henry was a handsome giant with a predilection for athletics; he hunted and shot; played tennis and wrestled with the best of them. In addition he was intelligent, a capable musician, quite well-seen in theology, a patron of the arts and learning…… A month after his father’s death, Henry fulfilled his dying wish by marrying Catherine of Aragon, six years older than himself….. The very fact of Henry’s peaceful accession was a triumph for his father’s policy; the blood of both the Roses had at last mingled in one unquestioned claimant to the throne.”
[It was while typing the above paragraph that I lost my Internet connection for a couple of days. I have therefore made this Part One of the review which I will continue in Part Two.]


I wondered what had happened to you. An excellent Part 1!
Thank you very much, Merril
You did quite well, despite internet trouble.
Thank you very much, GP
What a lot of trouble you have gone to – thank you for the interest and thoroughness of the first part!
Much appreciated, Anne.
Well darn! I really enjoyed those excerpts. Such good writing! Elton made it interesting without taking annoying liberties. Looking forward to Part II.
Thank you very much, Laurie
I did not know much about Henry VII and this was an eye opener, Derrick. I know a lot more about the remaining Tudors. Hope your Internet is restored sooner rather than later. Good review todate.
Thank you very much, Pat
I wondered where you were. You made up for lost time with this eloquently written review.
Thank you so much, Eugi
You’re welcome, Derrick.
Thank you for this review Derrick
Much appreciated, Sylvie
This is very interesting, Derrick, thanks! I’m glad your internet came back.
Much appreciated, John
The castle trips have been such an education on the Tudors for me
Thank you very much, Gary
Thank you for the review. A lot of information there. I’ve seen a movie or two on King Henry’s character so this gives light to some previous knowledge I gained from the movies.
His first task was to “convince the world and country he was really king”. That must have been quite some work. 😁
You are so right about the prose of G.R. Elton. This was pleasurable to follow. At least, the quotes you included are. This is a compelling collection.
Thank you so much, Crystal
Thanks for the review, Derrick. Elton’s astute observation caught my attention: “By being king, and by exploiting the great inherent strength of that office, Henry VII put himself into a position of such power that disagreement had to reach a very considerable pitch before it would translate itself into resistance.” It brought to mind the power of our current wannabe king.
Indeed, Rosaliene. Nothing much changes. Thank you very much.
An excellent review, Derrick! You are a fabulous reviewer! This was so interesting and a joy to read.
G. R. Elton is an excellent writer.
I have always been fascinated and interested in learning more about this time period in history…especially about the Kings…of course King Henry VIII was such a charismatic, complex AND paradoxical man. He always “captures” me in.
The illustrations are always fascinating to me.
Thank you for this Part 1! I await Part 2! 🙂
Glad your internet is back to working!
(((HUGS))) and ❤️❤️ for you and Jackie!!
Thank you so much from us both, Carolyn XX
I agree with you about the quality of Elton’s prose. It’s very engaging.
Thank you so much, Liz
You’re welcome, Derrick.
“In the Tudor age, men were far too quick to draw daggers, wield clubs, break heads and raise riots.”
Thinking about today’s riots and the growing knife crime amongst male youth, it seems that for some people, nothing has changed.” A super review, Derrick.
Thank you very much, Sue. There is so much that hasn’t changed
your reviews are great and I like how you shared this at the start:
“When reviewing fiction I tend to avoid details which will act as spoilers, yet include quotations which don’t give the game away. With history I have also to tell the story”
Your strategy pays off !
Looking forward to part 2
Thank you so much, Yvette
Excellent indeed
Thank you very much, Sheree
An interesting history and excellent review, Derrick. I remember that earlier post on King Richard III.
Thank you very much, Lavinia
An engaging read, yours and Eltons. I’m sorry about the internet. We’re at a complete loss when ours is disrupted.
Thank you very much, Alys. My biggest concern was that I couldn’t let you all know
I appreciate that. We all do. Your blog posts arrive like clockwork. I was relieved your absence was mundane.