In her introduction to my 1948 edition of Jane Austen’s acknowledged most popular novel Elizabeth Bowen tells us that, written when the author was 20, this work was rejected, so “the manuscript went into abeyance” for more than 15 years, until the success of ‘Sense and Sensibility’ prompted Austen to revise and then change the title to ‘Pride and Prejudice’. It is therefore her first book.
“Pride….[according to one of the writer’s characters]….is a very common failing….By all that I have ever read, I am convinced that it is very common indeed, that human nature is particularly prone to it, and that there are very few of us who do not cherish a feeling of self-complacency on the score of some quality or other, real or imaginary. Vanity and pride are different things, though the words are often used synonymously…… Pride relates more to our opinion of ourselves, vanity to what we would have others think of us.”
She uses ‘prejudice’ as the consequence of first impressions: “His character was decided. He was the proudest, most disagreeable man in the world, and everybody hoped that he would never come there again” after very brief acquaintance does not necessarily accurately define the man.
I see this book as a social excoriation of the period when the life of a woman depended on catching a suitable husband to provide her with security and status; and on her own beauty to attract him. Thus mothers needed to find a suitable target with assessable income, land, and property; and to encourage daughters to hunt for gentlemen who could be baited by their charms. Appearance is everything – beauty of the woman, splendour of the man.
“It was next to impossible that their cousin [a clergyman] should come in a scarlet [soldier’s] coat and it was now some weeks since they had received pleasure from the society of a man in any other colour.”
These young women were deemed past it as they approached 30. As such it is an admonishment of societal norms at the turn of the eighteenth century, and the time of the author’s coming of age.
“Without thinking highly either of men or of matrimony, marriage had always been her object; it was the only honourable provision for a well-educated young woman of small fortune and, however uncertain of giving happiness, must be their pleasantest preservation from want.”
“…. every day confirms my belief in the inconsistency of all human characters, and of the little dependance that can be placed on the appearance of either merit or sense.”
Austen examines the conflicts concerning the place of love in choosing a marriage partner, when balanced against the above-mentioned security.
The story is well crafted and prose flows along at a regular pace by way of conversation and letters. “How long has she been such a favourite? … and pray when am I to wish you joy?” answered by “That is exactly the question which I expected you to ask. A lady’s imagination is very rapid, it jumps from admiration to love, from love to matrimony, in a moment. I knew you would be wishing me joy.”
The author displays penetrating understanding of the complexities of human nature presented with sensitivity yet at times with caustic wit.
“The sisters, on hearing this, repeated three or four times how much they were grieved, how shocking it was to have a bad cold, and how excessively they disliked being ill themselves; and then thought no more of the matter.”
“In a softened tone she declared herself not at all offended; but continued to apologise for about a quarter of an hour.”
“Here, leading the way through every walk and crosswalk, and scarcely allowing them an interval to utter the phrases he asked for, every view was pointed out with a minuteness which left beauty entirely behind.”
As the story follows the relationships between her well-penned personnel Austen poses questions and surprises with a few hints along the way, and brings all to credible conclusions.
I have to say that, despite some major noble and likeable characters, for me there are too many unlikeable people, either devious, manipulative, sycophantic, or arrogant, to find the book as comic as many apparently do.
I see the book more as a satirical and social critique on the social status (including class and reputation) as well as the position of women in the time period rather than comical. Perhaps the latter opinion stems from the actors in the flmed verson of the novel? Several instances throughout the novel are fairly ludicrous to our modern ears, nonetheless, the theme is timeless. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it for my own pleasure as well as teaching it.
Thank you very much for these additional sound observations, Anne. I think the dramatisation perhaps overplayed the comic elements – not unusual.
I am a Jane Austen fan, and I don’t find the book comic, although it does have comedic elements Can there be any funnier scene than Mr. Collins rushing over to ask Charlotte Lucas for her hand in marriage just a day after he asked Elizabeth? Rather, I find Pride and Prejudice a sharply written book about class and the role of women and marriage in general. A rollicking comedy would not allow for those observations. The sharpness of the book saves it from being a silly romance with a silly happy ending. The sharpness gives the book depth and endurance.
Because I knew you were a fan I hoped you would agree with my seeing it as social commentary on “the role of women and marriage in general”. You have added fine analysis. Certainly that was a funny sequence, but the man was excruciatingly boring.
Yes, yes! And as for Mr. Collins…hoo-boy. Still, I sympathize with Charlotte and her decision to marry Mr. Collins. Another thing Jane Austen did so well was examine various aspects of marriage, the good and the bad.
Thanks for your review, Derrick. It’s been quite a while since I’ve read this book. I had no idea that it was really her first novel. Her understanding of the complexities of human nature is astounding for her young age. I’m thankful that we women in the West have other options these days.
Good points, Rosaliene. Thanks very much.
A very insightful review! I found the comedic elements to be black humor, which I tend to appreciate.
What puts me off is that such humour is largely at someone else
I understand.
In French, ‘humour’ is at one’s own expense.
‘esprit’ is generally at others’ expense. ‘Il faisait toujours de l’esprit aux dépens des autres’.
Needless to say, I prefer ‘humour’.
Me, too, Brian. This is a fine distinction
A very thorough review, Derrick. I didn’t realize this was her first written (at age 20!), but not first published novel.
Thanks very much, Merril
I have read regency romances which may or may not have been accurate, that people of the ton (London’s upper crust) were afraid to see Miss Austen as part of the invitees because they feared her biting commentary and concerned they might end of on one of her novels. Have no idea how fictional or improbable this notion actually was.
I would imagine there is a basis in reality, Pat. Thank you very much
I believe I have mentioned before that I read it for an English class assignment in high school and thought it dreadful “About nothing other than a mother trying to get her daughters married off.” But then saw the BBC version with Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle, and fell madly in love. The series certainly cultivated scenes of hilarity, and in particular I loved Mr. Bennett’s dry quips. The language you have quoted here makes me eager to read the book again, however. I am envious that Austen wrote it at age 20. If only I could settle down and finish one of my books already.
Thanks very much, Crystal. It matures well, but in my view really isn’t funny
You are so right about all the despicable characters – they keep things in a constant state of discomfort.
Great review Derrick!
Thank you very much, Diane
What a first novel.
Quite. Thanks very much, Gary
A very nice review.
Austen brought forth the social contrasts of her times, the mindset and position of women in society, the hypocrisy of the privileged class and the stereotypes of relationships.
But the number of characters in her novels make it a complex and hard read. At least for me.
Thank you very much, Geeta
I agree 🙂
An excellent, right on review!
(((HUGS))) ❤️❤️
Thank you so much, Carolyn XX
Thank you for the honest review. Not easy to not like such an icon (! am not that big a fan myself).
Much appreciated, Sylvie
This is a very interesting analysis of this book. I’ve never been a huge Austen fan but I have read this one. I enjoyed your commentary.
Thank you very much, Robbie
I like your analysis of the book.
Thank you very much, Rupali
I only saw the movie, but I enjoyed your analysis of the book, Derrick. I will have to read it at some point to see how well it matches my recollection of the movie.
Thank you very much, Lavinia.
Ms Austin had a gift for observation
She did, Sheree. Thanks very much
Hi Derrick, I enjoyed your review and I am not sure if you have seen the 1980 movie take of P&P? It is my favorite take on this book, with Elizabeth Garvie and David Rintoul – just so well done.
My LEAST favorite is the 2005 one with Keira Knightley – even though I normally like the movies she is in.
Thanks very much, Yvette. I haven’t seen either
Great work of literature have always been a mirror to the society. The era and its sensibilities have been presented in detail through Austen’s looking glass. I suspect the core human nature remains the same even today.
True and insightful, Uma. Thank you very much