Political Life – Government

G. M. Young’s next essay in the Folio Society’s ‘Victorian England’ begins with his definition of essence and history of government in general and how it came to be in England. “Every government that has been in this world, or is ever likely to be, is a system of of injunctions and restraints: do this – abstain from that. It may be more, but that it must be. And in the last analysis we can determine the distinguishing character of the system by asking what is the authority behind the command? According to the answer, we have the types of government familiar in the tradition of the schools – monarchic, aristocratic, popular, with all their variations and compromises……..every institution raises two questions: … why does it [and] why should it exist?

“So regarded, politics is an experimental science, and history is the record of the experiments…..two elements …. need to be kept in adjustment – the irrational element of custom, tradition, habit, making for stability, and the rational, critical element making for improvement….”

We learn of the interface between the Crown, the people, and their leaders, and how this has developed over the years from the unquestioned authority of the monarch, and via the Magna Carta, the transfer of that authority to the populace and their representatives. “Confidence, then, in the wisdom and impartiality of the Crown, is the second element in the public attitude to the monarchy……[the Prime Minister, when conveying laws to his or her Majesty] may find him[or her]self confronted with experience far wider than his [or her] own…..And knows that to whatever height of power and popularity he [or she] may have risen, he [or she] is not in the long run nearly so interesting a figure to the public as the [person addressed]…..who is their head; and the stability which it is the prime object of every constitution to assure is with us best pictured as a domestic stability; a projection, almost, of that primitive and most intense desire, the desire of the child for safety in the home.”

“The Act of 1875 which fully legitimated the trade unions went some way to revive the conception of Parliament as an assembly of estates; the land, the clergy, the merchant, the manufacturers, and now, the estate of labour.”

“Popularity comes and goes: from the moment he is chosen, a leader becomes the object of all manner of internal jealousy and intrigue; but in office or in opposition, an achieved reputation for parliamentary capacity is an abiding gift.” Thus Young could have written the story of the rapid turnaround of Prime Ministers we have experienced in the current decade.

The Poor Law Commission of 1882 and subsequent Reform Bills addressed the problems of poverty and consequently, health, housing, and homelessness. Taxation was introduced to redistribute the wealth of the nation to the benefit of those in need of welfare benefits

Whilst I enjoy Young’s literary writing style readers will note that the intermittent square-bracketed inserts demonstrate my struggle to restore a sexual balance to his prose.

____________

Later I watched the highlights of today’s third day of the first men’s cricket Test match between England and Pakistan.

We then dined on roast duck breasts; Yorkshire pudding; mashed potato; Brussels sprouts; our own runner beans, cauliflower, and carrots, with which Jackie drank Vineyards Juicy rosé, and I drank the Garnacha, still potable although opened a few days ago.

30 comments

  1. Thank you for your efforts on trying to restore a “sexual balance” to his prose. He does seem rather old fashioned in his writing, and I was surprised the book publication says 1999.

    It seems you must be feeling better now.

  2. So interesting. So many changes. So grateful for the good changes that have occurred.
    Thank you for your bracketed inserts.
    Wishing you and Jackie a wonderful day! 🙂
    (((HUGS))) and ❤️❤️

  3. Young writes at one point, that he was 19 when Victoria died. He is therefore a product of a time when women had no vote, and when he wrote the book in the 1930s, so it is 90 years old, and women had had very little chance to make their mark. An interesting man.

  4. “Confidence… in the wisdom and impartiality of the Crown” (or the highest power?) That is a very good definition. Seldom applied these days…
    Thanks for the thought, Derrick.
    How did England fare against my birth country?
    Happy weekend.

    1. If Pakistan is your birth country they were walloped by England. You moved around so much I can’t remember where you were born. Thanks very much, Brian

      1. Haha! I like “walloped”. You have a fine vocabulary my friend. No worry: I have indeed moved around so much that at times I wonder: “have I been there”? Now I do appreciate your frequent mentions of curry either at home or outside… (I like chicken massala amongst other dishes…)

  5. Young’s study of the socio-political evolution in Britain is interesting and authoritative. Democracy, however, needs a serious rethink in current times. The brazen appeasement of nefarious elements of the population for their votes, coupled with overlooking activities that sometimes border on criminality, is increasingly becoming the undoing of the institution. India, which appears to have adopted the British system of governance, is one example. Its misconceived and increasingly aggressive mission of social purging through reservation is not only smothering talent but also fostering incompetence and the general decay of society, and is beginning to resemble the Cultural Revolution in China.

    But reservations get votes, and therein lies the problem. What began as a corrective measure has become an electoral instrument that few political parties dare question.

    I don’t want to mention sensitive issues like the ‘grooming gangs’ and the increasingly aggressive posturing of migrants of a certain sect in Europe at large, but they all point to the disintegration of democracy. Indeed, the rot will eventually assume pandemic proportions, necessitating a rethinking of governance and political systems.

    My apologies for this rather unexpected rant. I seem to have wandered some distance from Young and his study of Britain into the more treacherous terrain of contemporary politics. But then, that is one of the hazards of a good book: it sets off trains of thought that do not always stop at the intended station.

  6. Fascinating reading material, Derrick. I guess in some societies the same principles as in Britain are not important. This must be why there is so much corruption and mismanagement in the world.

  7. A brilliant and deeply engaging read, Derrick!
    Young’s approach to politics as an “experimental science” that balances tradition and reform is timeless.

  8. I read this post with great interest, in an attempt to add understanding to some of our present day politics. You did that as well, I see. What tumult with the series of PMs, that I wonder if even G.M. Young would have been able to anticipate such a situation. I am grateful for the brackets! Thank you for making it important to support equality in prose.

  9. Thank you for this, Derrick. Young’s prose is thought-provoking, and your review/narration is excellent. I seem to forget so much these days, I forgot that I forgot how speech and writing used to use the ‘universal gender’ when referring to humans in general. Honestly, in those days, with that usage, it never occurred to me to consider it restrictive or discriminatory.

Leave a comment