The Victorian Ethos: Before And After Victoria; And Late Victorian Women

This post covers the next two consecutive essays in The Folio Society’s ‘Victorian England’ because they seem to be clearly related. Gertrude Himmelfarb, in the first, suggests that the period is “too long, the tempo of change too rapid, the cast of characters too motley to permit of generalisation….” as ‘Victorianism’

“Some of the most eminent Victorian worthies were also the most notorious flouters of convention: John Stuart Mill, who courted Mrs Taylor for almost twenty years with her husband hovering in the background; George Eliot, [the male pseudonym of the female writer] who lived with G. H. Lewes for more than twenty years quite as if his wife did not exist…….And there were those who managed to offend propriety in reverse: Carlyle and Ruskin, for example, whose desire for marriage was so much more compelling than their desire for sexual relations that they lived in permanent celibacy with their wives……” Nevertheless “Ethics, religion, and philosophy, changing in themselves and shifting in relation to each other, merged to constitute a unique ethos.”

Both writers consider the class differences of the people in their subjects and how these impact on their lives. Pat Thane, the second, in focussing on women, speaks of the general improvement of their health, living conditions, and consequent length of life over the period of two thirds of a century. My extracts tend to be general but Professor Thane does tell of the effects of different disparities in class.

“Whatever the precise overall picture, the period saw changes of dramatic importance concerning female health. Above all, more women felt, and were, able to control not only the number of their pregnancies and the size of their families but could feel, as a result, a potential for control over their lives that was historically unprecedented.” Birth control was becoming an option. “As women gave birth to fewer babies and ceased child-bearing at younger ages the survival chances of both infants and mothers were enhanced.”

Annie Besant was an ardent proponent of birth control and socialism.

Although it remained difficult, before this time it had been impossible for a woman to obtain a divorce in our male dominated society. “Gradually, it seems, in complex ways still incompletely explored, divorce court judges were moving towards a conception of marriage as a contract embodying reciprocal rights and obligations between husband and wife which both were expected to observe, rather than as a relationship of patriarchal domination and dependence.”

The importance of motherhood was pivotal. “….there was an enhanced public emphasis upon motherhood and the importance of stable family life at a time when more women than before were challenging women’s expected role and the family faced an unprecedented level of criticism.” Women were questioning whether they even wanted to marry or manage a family.

“There is no reason to doubt that the largest single female paid occupation was domestic service.” “Most servants were the sole general servant in a not very wealthy household, hence the harshness of their working lives…..” “However, a significant proportion of middle-class households were well enough off for everyday comfort, but could not afford to keep their daughters in idleness, perhaps indefinitely if they did not marry. This material reality encouraged many middle-class men to support improved secondary education for girls, as a path towards a respectable career, probably in teaching. Fewer of them showed enthusiasm for female higher education, which threatened to tempt women to compete in the masculine professions. This period saw the unprecedented expansion of serious education for females at private secondary, teacher-training and university levels….”

Being a wife at home managing the family and its income was often regarded as unpaid drudgery; and “In practice a very high proportion of working-class households depended upon earnings from the wife at some point in their life cycle.”

The more wealthy women could choose whether they took paid employment or engaged in ‘lady bountiful’ charitable work.

26 comments

  1. It is seems to me that this is accurate:
    “the period is “too long, the tempo of change too rapid, the cast of characters too motley to permit of generalisation….” as ‘Victorianism’”

  2. Yes, very interesting. Too many people tend to look back at “ the olden days” as a time of unchanging bliss. History proves otherwise. Ignorance combined with nostalgia is not good and can be very destructive, as we have seen in this country.

  3. I enjoyed savouring the fascinating vignettes of Victorian England, an age so often reduced to stiff propriety and rigid convention, yet evidently full of contradictions, subtle rebellions and profound social change. The unconventional private lives of some of its most eminent figures are particularly revealing. Mill, George Eliot, Carlyle and Ruskin hardly fit the neat picture we tend to have of Victorian respectability.

    Equally fascinating is the changing world of women, from marriage, motherhood and domestic service to birth control, education and the beginnings of greater independence. Class, of course, shaped how much of this new freedom a woman could actually enjoy. It all makes Victorian England feel much more complex, and much more human, than the familiar stereotype.

  4. A fascinating post for me, given that I set Louisa firmly in the late Victorian era. I know more than the average yogi bear about how divorce worked in NSW, but that Annie Bessant promoted contraception had passed me by. Let alone what methods may have been available beyond the obvious abstinence or timing. You sent me down a little research rabbit hole.

  5. Two very interesting essays! Thank you for reviewing them and sharing them with us! Always eye-opening to see how women were treated in different times in history…and how things changed, and when things changed. I so appreciate the men and women who worked and helped to make life better, healthier, safer, etc., for women and children! (((HUGS))) and ❤️❤️
    PS…one of my mother’s relatives live from 1818 to 1894…Amelia Jenks Bloomer…she worked to make life better for females. 🙂

  6. For me, it is a new and revealing thought that a family might be wealthy enough for comfort, but not enough for the daughters not to get married, and in case marriage wasn’t certain, then the father was willing to fund an education. The end result was women’s education, which was an accidental (and wonderful) unintended consequence. ha ha. It also explains how, even to this day, families and the women themselves would embrace university, and the moment a man proposed, they tossed it all aside. I always thought it was mind boggling. But now it makes sense. Education, in those instances, is the back up plan so the daughter wouldn’t be a drain on the family, and not the main plan.

    1. Such a thoughtful response, Crystal. You may know that I didn’t go to university because I chose to earn money to help the family. Three of my younger siblings, including Elizabeth, did

Leave a comment