This penultimate essay in the Folio Society history of ‘Victorian England’ was penned by F.B.Smith.
“The atheist campaign in the nineteenth century found its most thorough expression in the mission to the working classes. In Charles Southwell, the Holyoakes, Bradlaugh and their allies, the cause found apostles as self-sacrificing and implacable as any of their evangelical Christian contemporaries. They preached atheism in the market-place, suffered the hostility of mobs and endured imprisonment as common felons.”
“The first avowedly atheist periodical, Southwell’s ‘Oracle of Reason’ appeared in 1841.” “…Religion [it postulated] was immoral: it was destructive of personal happiness, intellectually false; anachronistic and in general socially pernicious.”
The missioners took issue with the tenets of religion; the literal veracity of the bible; and basic principles of right and wrong. “Man could only be ‘strictly moral’ if he desired good for its own sake, that is, if he became ‘a practical atheist’. To do good in the hope of future reward or fear of future punishment was to make man servile like the brutes or meanly self-interested…”. “No creature could be so evil as to deserve eternal torment.”
“…. the atheists were careful never to declare the impossibility of God. They took the view that the onus of proving God’s existence lay with those who asserted it and they delighted in eliminating the inferential arguments.” And, of course, faith depends upon lack of proof.
Smith details writers and speeches for and against the movement, particularly in relation to the Bible as, for example, discrepancies in the gospel and the history quoted. They questioned the power of prayer; and how a loving God could allow so much harm to go on.
As experienced by many political or religious movements the writer explores internal splits and differences of opinion and states that “The factious history of the atheists….” was an ultimate weakness, and that “…..their effort was minute beside the enormous reserves of manpower, money and official approval which sustained the great Christian revival and building campaigns of the century.”
“The foundations of their anti-theological position had also crumbled…..”[leaving] the atheists with no real dogmas to fight, at least in British Protestantism.”
“By its own admission, the movement largely failed to indoctrinate the British lower classes with its notions of secular duty. The view that duty had precedence over happiness apparently had little appeal to people whose lives had already too much of the one and too little of the other. Moreover the atheist idea of duty for its own sake made little sense to working men whose everyday existence was controlled by a system of goads, rewards and punishments.”
This evening we dined on baked gammon; white and sweet mashed potato; leek and spinach compote; carrots; and cauliflower cheese with its chopped leaves; Jackie drank Franziskaner Weissbier and I drank Limestone Coast Merlot 2025.
Funny how strict their moral arguments were.
Thank you very much, Pat
Interesting. I’ve had two dear, caring friends (now long deceased) who were atheists. They used similar arguments for their position.
That is interesting, too, Rosaliene. Thank you very much
Learned something new today, that’s for sure. I didn’t realize there were atheist movements in the mid-1800s. I can see how working-class folks might have thought that they were already doing their duty and didn’t need anymore.
Thank you so much, Laurie
“They preached atheism in the market-place, suffered the hostility of mobs and endured imprisonment as common felons.”
Thankfully we have a constitutional law upholding the freedom of speech
In today’s world. Shocking but that was the dark ages.
Thank you so much, Holly
I think, class distinction of society is still religion’s biggest barrier , Derrick
Thanks very much, Ivor
An interesting essay. I’m not a believer, but I can understand why this “mission” failed when the lives of the working class were already so difficult. All your vegetable sides sound delicious.
Thank you so much, Merril
Interesting essay. I agree with “No creature could be so evil as to deserve eternal torment.” (with the key word being eternal) and support anyone’s right to be an atheist. Reason and historical consideration are important in considering biblical discrepancies.
Thank you so much, JoAnna
I had not heard of The Atheist Mission before. It strikes me that whether believer or atheist,
people sure do like to tell other people how to live.
Good point, Julie. Thank you very much
I am an atheist and your point struck me as well. I wish EVERYONE would stop trying so hard to make others believe the same things they believe. 🙂
Indeed
Interesting. Atheists tend to not recognize how similar their dogma and beliefs are to organized religion.
Thank you very much, Cindy
So interesting. I knew nothing of this. Thank you for sharing this with us, Derrick.
(((HUGS))) and ❤️❤️ for Jackie and you! 🙂
Much appreciated Carolyn XX
What a fascinating read 🙂 🙂 🙂
Thank you very much, Anne
No doubt the Atheist mission was another movement led not by women, but by men eager to assert their dominance and create divisions .
Thanks very much Sue. They were mostly men, but “Emma Martin, the converted former editress of the Baptist Magazine agreed that, as God was immutable and had foreordained every part of every life, prayer could not alter events.”
I had never heard of this level of atheist activism and I find it fascinating. Also, so telling that they were just as obnoxious as religious people in pressing their points. Like the Christian extremists here who point at Islamic extremists and complain – I see their behavior identical. I am an atheist but I find much value in faith for people, from what I’ve witnessed. I would never try to take that away from them.
That is what I think and say about other faiths. Thank you very much, Crystal
I echo Crystal’s comment. This was a VERY enlightening post.
Thanks very much, Gwen
It always interests me that people always want to put their ideas about religion, or not, to others and try and convince them how right they are in their beliefs. I don’t care what other people believe. I’m rather self centered like that and only really care what I believe.
So right, Robbie
“The view that duty had precedence over happiness apparently had little appeal to people whose lives had already too much of the one and too little of the other” – too right!
Thanks very much, Sheree