This essay, by John Cannon, is the seventh in the second section of ‘England in the Eighteenth Century’.
It opens with “Frederick, Lord North, has an unenviable reputation as the worst prime minister of all time.” Cannon reminds us that his first ten years in Parliament were more successful. “After a spell of two years as chancellor of the Exchequer, North took over the premiership from the Duke of Grafton at a moment of acute crisis…… Within a few months of Lord North’s taking office, the situation was transformed….Before the year [1770] was out the opposition was in complete disarray….”
“…he was a hard-working and capable administrator with ten years in office behind him. He rarely attempted wit, his delivery was portentous and his articulation far from distinct, but his speeches were relevant and seldom tried the patience of the House. Not least among his political assets were his good humour and his imperturbability….he possessed a remarkable resilience, bobbing up under pressure like a cork.”
After “a gang of Rhode Island radicals seized the revenue cutter ‘Gasp’, wounded the captain and burned the vessel. The British ministers retorted by authorising the governor to seek out those responsible and present them for trial.” The culprits were not found, and “The Boston Tea Party a year later repeated the affront on the grand scale and the ministry responded with four coercive Acts designed to bring the colonies back to obedience.”
North completely misjudged the situation. Although he realised the issue was now about whether the British retained any power in America he did not know what would be required to resolve the issue. “The first two years of fighting in America passed without any decisive encounter.” The defeat in ” Saratoga was Lord North’s political death-warrant.” He spent four years pleading with the King to allow him to leave the premiership, but George was very fond of him and needed his support. “Each effort the hapless man made to escape was stymied by fate or by the king.” It was important to the Crown that the leader of the government should be the least likely to embark light-heartedly on conflict.
“His misjudgement of American affairs was one he shared with most of his generation: he was no wiser than they were, which is in part why they found him so comfortable a leader. He was essentially a man of business above his station – a truth which his superb debating ability concealed from many of his supporters but never from North himself.” “From beginning to end North maintained that the war against America was a war to uphold parliamentary authority.” At the same time the American colonies realised that the English did not have the power to exercise it.