Written in the perfectly phrased and clearly expressed language and precise detail that one would expect from a Cambridge history graduate, Antony Grey has given us the story of his and others’ efforts “Towards Homosexual Emancipation” which is the subheading of his book, ‘Quest for Justice’. The work, published by Sinclair Stevenson in 1992, contains a number of illustrations, of which I have

selected two: Grey himself and
Sir John Wolfenden, who offered ‘A Beam of Light’.
Opening with a chapter on ‘The Roots of Oppression’ we are told that “Homosexual and bisexual people can (and commonly do) experience deep, passionate love for someone else of their own sex, and not merely lust or sexual indulgence. That two men, or two women, can form profoundly loving attachments that are as authentic and meaningful to them as those of happily married heterosexual couples is an essentially straightforward concept but it is not comprehended by many ‘straight’ people who persist in imagining that homosexuality is merely a depraved and degenerate way of getting cheap thrills.”
“During the first half of this [20th] century, homosexuality in Britain was shrouded in a conspiracy of silence. Harsh laws compounded social ignorance and homosexuals’ fearfulness. Nevertheless, as biographies and memoirs of the period indicate the ‘silent years’ between the 1890s and the 1950s saw a great deal of homosexual behaviour, most of it discreet and undetected.
“The law imposed a heavy burden of unnecessary misery upon those – especially the sensitive young – who discovered homosexual feelings within themselves.”
“As Lord Wolfenden recalled in his autobiography,[when the Wolfenden committee was appointed in 1954] the topics with which we were to be concerned [homosexuality and prostitution] were not mentioned in polite society. Most ordinary people had never heard of homosexuality; and of those who had the great majority regarded it with something nearer to disgust than to understanding….”
Allan Horsfall, in ‘Battling for Wolfenden’ says “Had it been conceivable to produce a gay man’s survival guide at that time it would have urged him never to reveal his name or address…..” and much more detail we are today advised to conceal when avoiding internet scamming today.
“On 5 September 1957 the Wolfenden report was published. It achieved shock headlines with its main recommendation that ‘homosexual behaviour between consenting adults in private be no longer a criminal offence….”
The Homosexual Law Reform Society, and the Albany Trust, in each of which Antony Grey was a leading figure, spearheaded pressure for the Wolfenden recommendations to be enshrined in law, the Trust being the more involved in information, training, and counselling.
Grey details the often acrimonious Parliamentary debates that followed before the law was reformed in the Sexual Offences Act of 1967. We are told that most discussion focussed on the acts that men were assumed to practice rather than the realities outlined in the first chapter of this review. He speaks of “the unreality of the legal distinction between the state of being homosexual and homosexual acts.” What was meant by “in private”, “consent”, and the upper age limit permitted were constantly wrestled with. The desire to protect from abuse rather than to punish was key issue. Our author is of the opinion that nature is more significant than nurture and that most people know of their orientation by the age of 6.
Although the debates were focussed on the actual or imagined behaviour of men, women were hardly mentioned, supposedly because it was thought that there were no lesbians. Yet “the first openly homophile group to be started in Britain was for women” in 1964.
Antony Grey names lists of people involved in all aspects of his journey. It is at once a prosaic history of an era and of his own life. It is not without humour. When told “Some women can spot a “queer” in a minute….. [he] suggested that MI5 and the Foreign Office should seek out and recruit these lynx-eyed ladies.” “…she always wrote her diaries on rice paper so that they could be instantly eaten in case of emergency.” In America “The first question From a radio reporter was almost inevitable: was I homosexual? Wary of the implications for my entry visa, I half humorously pleaded the Fifth Amendment.”
In the early 1980s “The advent of AIDS brought a vicious escalation of homophobia. The consequent depths to which some public discussion of homosexuality and other sexual issues sank, reminiscent of the most bigoted utterances of the 1950s, has been well documented by Richard Davenport-Hines in his impressive study ‘Sex, Death and Punishment’. The urgent need to get some constructive social initiatives going to counteract this new wave of prejudice led me in the mid-1980s to undertake some AIDS-related work with Parliament, in the counselling and training field, and also in assessing the likely longer-term social impact of AIDS.”
It was during this period that I had met and collaborated with Antony Grey in devising a course for Local Authority Social Work Departments on the subject. A representative of the Terence Higgins Trust had visited me in my capacity as a Social Services Area Manager. I had heard of neither AIDS nor the trust. Soon I was in Antony’s lounge envying his complete collection of Folio Society books as we embarked on a series of meetings to design the course. He provided the detailed knowledge while I devised our course methods.
Antony took on the job of selling it to Social Services Departments. There were no takers.
The author finishes with “Having spent so much of my life attempting to educate the public about the real nature of homosexuality and the problems arising out of pervasive ignorance, I put forward the following basic points which should be incorporated into sex education programmes:…..[ the first of which is]
“Homosexuality is a natural variation of temperament and sexual impulse. It is a state of being: a mode of experiencing oneself. It is not a disease, a disability or an impairment; and it is compatible with the highest physical, creative, moral, spiritual, and social development. Homosexual people constitute a typical cross-section of humanity, not differing significantly (save in their sexual orientation) from their fellow men and women. Homosexual people down the ages have been amongst those of outstanding achievement in all walks of life. Their manifold contributions to human creativity, science and culture deserve acknowledgement.” There are two pages comprising nine points.
After I had drafted this we dined on baked gammon, ratatouille, runner beans, carrots, cauliflower with its chopped leaves, and Portobello mushrooms, with which Jackie drank Erdinger Weisbier and I finished the Côtes du Rhône.
