Published in 1990, this essay, the fifth, by Sir Lewis Namier, in the second section of Roy Porter’s ‘England in the Eighteenth Century’, as its title suggests, deals with the nature of the man, perhaps harshly termed the mad King.
“In the eighteenth century, a proper balance between king, Lords, and Commons, that is, the monarchical, aristocratic, and representative elements of the Constitution acting as checks on each other, was supposed to safeguard the property and privileges, the lives and liberty of the subjects…….. The technique of parliamentary opposition was fully established long before its most essential aim, which is to force a change of government was recognised as legitimate.” George was accused of ruling not through the ministers of his own choice whom he avowed in public, but through a hidden gang of “Obscure and sinister ‘King’s Friends’.”, one of whom was John Stuart, 3rd Earl of Bute, whom the king, before falling out with him, regarded as an important friend and mentor.
Lord Waldegrave, who had been governor to George as the Prince of Wales between 1752 and 1756, wrote in 1758 a ‘penetrating and just’ character sketch, which held firm unchanged over the next 50 years: ‘His parts, though not excellent, will be found very tolerable, if ever they are properly exercised. He is strictly honest, but wants that frank and open behaviour which makes honesty appear amiable…. His religion is free from all hypocrisy, but is not of the most charitable sort; he has rather too much attention to the sins of his neighbour. He has spirit, but not of the active kind; and does not want resolution, but it is mixed with too much obstinacy. He has great command of his passions, and will seldom do wrong, except when he mistakes wrong for right; but as often as this shall happen, it will be difficult to undeceive him, because he is uncommonly indolent, and has strong prejudices. His want of application and aversion to business would be far less dangerous, was he eager in the pursuit of pleasure: for the transition from pleasure to business is both shorter and easier than from a state of total inaction. He has a kind of unhappiness in his temper, which, if it be not conquered before it has taken too deep a root, will be a source of frequent anxiety. Whenever he is displeased, his anger does not break out with heat and violence; but he becomes sullen and silent, and retires to his closet: not to compose his mind by study or contemplation, but merely to enjoy the melancholy enjoyment of his own ill humour. Even when the fit is ended, unfavourable symptoms very frequently return, which indicate that on certain occasions his Royal Highness has to correct a memory.’
Years later “the same high claims on himself, and the same incapacity to meet real situations he was faced with: hence his continued dependence on others”, successively Bute, Cumberland, Pitt, Chatham, and North.
“A great deal of the pattern of George III’s behaviour throughout life can be traced back to his upbringing.” He was given a painful consciousness of his inadequacy….. Excessive demands on a child, complete with wholesome exhortations, are fit to reduce it to a state of hebetude from which it is not easy to recover.”
“He spent his young years cut off from intercourse with boys of his own age, till he himself ceased to desire it….. Isolation by itself would be apt to suggest to a child that there was something wrong with those he had to shun; but this he was probably told I so many words….So the boy spent joyless years in a well-regulated nursery, the nearest approach to a concentration camp: lonely but never alone, constantly watched and discussed, never safe from the wisdom and goodness of the grown-ups; never with anyone on terms of equality, exalted yet oppressed by deferential adults….[he] could not hit back as a child would among children: he could merely retire and nurture his griefs and grievances….”
“I have given here a picture of George III as seen in his letters, ‘warts and all’. What I have never able to find is the man arrogating power to himself, the ambitious schemer out to dominate, the intriguer dealing in an underhand fashion with his ministers; in short, any evidence for the stories circulated about him by very clever and eloquent contemporaries. “…..perhaps it was his deeper kindness, his real piety, and sincere wish to do good…” [that] “… more and more endeared him to the people.”
Namier says [George’s]” insanity was a form of manic depression.”
I prefer what Polly Putnam, curator of Kew Palace, on 22nd March 2024 published in https://www.hrp.org.uk/blog/the-kings-malady-george-iiis-mental-illness-explored/ : “We can never really know what caused George III’s illness, but we do know that the King suffered greatly both physically and mentally.” Accounts differ wildly and can be interpreted in many ways: These inconsistencies have led historians to ‘diagnose’ the King with many different illnesses and conditions including arsenic poisoning, porphyria, and most recently bipolar disorder.”
I recommend Putnam’s article for further reading.
This evening we dined on Jackie’s wholesome lamb’s heart and liver casserole; mashed sweet and white potato; firm carrots; and tender broccoli, with which she drank Vineyards Juicy rosé and I drank more of the merlot.
