Unruly

Subtitled ‘A History of England’s Kings and Queens’, David Mitchell’s ‘Unruly’ takes us from ‘The Mists of Time’ to 1603 when Elizabeth I handed the reigns to James VI of Scotland. I was disappointed that he stopped there.

The paperback, produced in 2023, contains three collections of illustrations with the author’s captions.

I have only included the pages from the first set, in order to preserve my copy as best I can. Clicking on any image will access the gallery, enabling enlargement.

Describing himself in the text as a comedian Mitchell is much more than that. Yes. He is so entertaining in his humour as to keep us laughing. But he is also a most unorthodox historian who really knows his subject. Or at least that much of it with which I am familiar. That is, quite a lot. In amongst all the rollicking fun this work is also good for revision. Possibly not for exams. He is a most engaging script writer, actor, and TV personality.

The author’s style adopts a conversational stance. We feel he is speaking directly to us. Mind you, he must be grateful for the trial of ‘Lady Chatterley’s Lover’ which took place before he was a blush on anyone’s cheek, and freed the way for him to use the current vernacular in his idiosyncratic colourful manner. Had I used such language in my youth I would have no doubt got a right rollicking for fuck’s sake!

He also displays compassion and sensitivity to the monarchical lot, although he slags off many of them. “We can’t know what their feelings really were. There are so many centuries between us and them and their world was, by our standards, weird. But they still ate and drank and lived and died and hoped and lusted and feared and felt lonely.” “People with royal blood never undergo anything that uncomfortable any more, except at Gordonstoun.” “He wasn’t the best of medieval kings but neither was he one of the many who simply couldn’t do the job.” “Doubt is a dangerous thing….We’ve seen how doubt over the line of succession bred violence and discord, and we’re going to keep seeing that. That’s going to get boring. A key skill in a medieval ruler is eliminating doubt, and ruthlessness is part of that. The knowledge that, if crossed, the king will respond with immediate reflex savagery, no matter who is doing it or why, is in a sense reassuring.” “He was passive and trapped, reduced to working on his music like a teenager in his bedroom.” “Was this entitlement the reason he never troubled to marry and beget an heir? It’s a very unusual choice for a monarch at this time and suspicion that he was gay isn’t enough to explain it. Royal marriages weren’t usually love matches. The business of impregnation could generally be managed within couples where there was no mutual attraction.”

“It is a lamentable fact that the care system fails many of the children entrusted to it. A family environment needs to be exceptionally terrible – murderous, malevolently endangering – before a child isn’t better off there than in care. It’s a sad failure of the state and calls into question the extreme fastidiousness of the adoption process. Good luck adopting if you smoke, but the outcomes for children brought up in the households of smokers are far better than for those whose childhoods are spent in care…..” So Mitchell likens the childhood of one king who had no parents. My own long experience in the field would take issue with some of this but I cannot deny that it is a sensitive comparison in the context in which our provocative author presents it.

In extracts I have included I have done my very best to avoid spoilers, although Mitchell has no such qualms, and acknowledges them in parenthesis.

“Villas were abandoned and, all over the country, hoards of coins and valuables were buried in the hope of being dug up by their owners when the situation improved. It was a vain hope. Instead they were dug up by metal detectorists over a thousand years after the owners had all rotted to dust….” shows the author’s ability to link with elements of today. “It’s remarkable how many kings over the centuries have been obsessed with hunting. It’s like American Presidents with golf.” “People found it much easier to believe in a rose-tinted view of the past than a utopian future. They still do: hence ‘Take Back Control’ and ‘Make America Great Again’ ” offers an insightful version. Further insight is shown in “The thought that disasters are your fault is comforting, on some level. It gives you the illusion of control when, in truth, something horrible came out of the blue and ruined your life.” Again: “Letting people win is a great way of shutting them up. If only it had worked on Nigel Farage.”

He generally likes to play with words, as in “He was one of the getting things done sort of saint rather than the getting-done-in kind.” Occasionally he diverts into etymology: “In fact, the term ’emperor’ started as a euphemism. Rome, having become a republic, loathed the notion of kings. ‘Emperor’ derived from imperator, which means a ‘military commander’ they weren’t horrible kings, just trusty commanders, in the same way that Stalin was just a nice reliable general secretary rather than anything showy or threatening like a president or tsar.”

Mitchell is not big on religion, but it does feature in the lives of his subjects, one of whom “…..already had a Christian wife…so he was less inclined than many of his contemporaries to murder Christians on sight.”

The book is most enjoyable. Entertaining, amusing, and educational. We cannot ask for more than that.

After I drafted the review we enjoyed drinks on the decking then repeated yesterday’s beef burger meal and finished our respective wines.

38 comments

  1. Mitchell’s book sounds lively and humorous while at the same time being factual. That is no small thing. History school books would benefit from that combination.

  2. I enjoy Mr. Mitchell’s wonderful humor and acting! 🙂
    Funny and a historian…sounds like a most wonderful combination! Fab photos and author’s captions!
    Thank you for this excellent review, Derrick! I was looking forward to it! What an interesting and enjoyable read…your review! And the book sounds like it is, too! 🙂
    (((HUGS))) ❤️❤️

  3. Ah, Mr. Mitchell is my sort of author, “He generally likes to play with words,” … thank you for an interesting and enjoyable review, Derrick

  4. A very thorough review! It sounds like an interesting and enjoyable book, Derrick. You’ve given us a good taste of the author’s wit and humor in text and captions.

  5. I can see why you would enjoy this book. It looks interesting. I like the helmet that looks like it has sunglasses.

  6. David Mitchell is talented in so many directions. I look forward to more Ludwig and anytime he and Bob Mortimor are together on WILTY is a treat. Even on that fun show, his intelligence is clear. I’m putting the book on my reading list.

  7. What a wonderful review, Derrick. I enjoy Mr. Mitchell’s sense of humor, and the illustrations are beautiful.

  8. I am not familiar with David Mitchell but he’s rather right up my alley. I am now going to put this book on my list. History + comedy = a book well worth the time spent. This review was engaging! And I am just dying at the author captions. “…let the garden get on top of them.” so funny.

Leave a comment