You Must Remember This

Joyce Carol Oates, in the title of this novel references the iconic song from the classic film, Casablanca, raising the question of the meaning of a kiss.

First published by E. P. Dutton, New York in 1987, and in the UK by MacMillan London Limited in 1988, the story, set in the early 1950s, accurately evidences the background of world politics and cultural events of the period; reminders for someone like me growing up during the post World War 2 decades.

Oates is a master of descriptive prose, engaging all our senses as in “Enid was in the living room crouched by the stairs around the corner from them but she could picture her mother’s flushed face, the wide cheekbones, eyes pinched at the corners, narrowed. Momma would be standing with her feet apart, arms wound in the loose fold of her apron as she did when she was nervous and talking fast, not always knowing what she said. Close up you could feel the heat coming off her, and the smells that were hers – something rich, milky, biscuity, over-sweet – very intensified……” She carries readers along in the company of her protagonists’ minds and bodies, reflecting their thoughts and their language.

“Flushed face” in the above example, is one example of the writer’s alliteration. Others are “scrupulous sinner to scan”; “….customers at the cosmetics counter….”; “She also likes similes, as in “….her heart rocked like a pendulum…” and “…eyes brimming with tears like water in a shallow container the slightest agitation would spill….” and metaphors such as “….lifting his chin from beneath, shaking free a rainbow of moisture, a flying skein of blood……”

Our writer is able to picture beauty as well. “By night, lights winked along the shores of l’Isle-Verte where the yachts were moored, in the distance Grande Isle, then Isle à La Motte, which even by day had the appearance of unbroken pine forest – just wilderness. Most mornings a chill gauzy mist lay over the lake which burned away by nine or ten o’clock so that the islands were defined slowly, one by one, finally the mountains in the distance; always there was the nervous slap of waves against the rocky beach and the sharp odor of the pine trees close about the cabin mixing with sleep, dreams.” Even this extract closes with a sense of the tension which is never far from the narrative. “Yet there was a subtle rhythm to the slapping of the water, a hidden melody.” follows in another 5 pages.

Much of the shocking, visceral, prose carries the reader at a breakneck speed as the themes of incest, child abuse, suicide and murderous violence race through the book, which as the blurb says probes the divisions between the American Dream and the American nightmare. At times I had to lay it down for a few days rest from the action scenes, particularly those of age-inappropriate incest and pulverising pugilism into which Oates drags us.

Another regular theme is the inability to leave or to prevent the following of a path once embarked upon it. “Do it! You can’t be stopped!” is one example of a constant refrain. Post-war conformity was challenged by Oates’s mostly less privileged characters, seeking fulfilment come what may.

The excellent jacket illustration is by Vincent S. Kirsch.

This afternoon and evening I watched the Nations Championship rugby matches between Fiji and Scotland; between South Africa and Wales; and between England and Argentina.

During the time separating the last two games we dined on fat free beef burgers; fried onions and Portobello mushrooms; mashed potato and carrot; boiled carrots and Broccoli, with which Jackie drank Erdinger Weissbier and I drank Pierre Jaurant Pays d’Oc Merlot 2024..

40 comments

  1. Thanks for the review, Derrick. I can appreciate your need to put the book down during periods of intense action in the dark places of the story. Such is the power of great storytelling.

  2. It was curious what you’d say about the book. I can see why you’d need to put the book aside for a bit. Long ago, I read a book of her short stories. They were very disturbing, but memorable. I can still remember the horror and disgust I felt when I read one of them (about being in a supermarket where everything was rotting. I believe it was Thanksgiving). That is a great book cover!

    I wonder how many books, stories, shows, etc. have used that song for inspiration! There was the TV show, As Time Goes By.

  3. Hello Derrick, I appreciate this author’s use of poetic devices such as alliteration which she uses brilliantly. Thank you for a review of her work.

  4. This kind of writing is inspiring for me. I will remember your reviews for when I am trying to improve my own writing. The things that capture your attention and appreciation are also the things I value, and would like to do with my own writing.

  5. At a time when domestic and child abuse is referred to as a never-before-seen pandemic, it is timely to remind ourselves it was ever thus – simply not in the public eye. That we have always known, yet failed to remedy it, is alarming. It sounds as if Oates has not shied from revealing the dark underbelly of a civilised society.

  6. Beautifully descriptive writing, but I don’t think I could read it with those themes racing at breakneck speed through the book. If you had to put it down for breaks, I would too, but don’t know if I would be able to pick it up again. Perhaps the overcoming of challenges was worth it.

  7. I thoroughly enjoyed reading both the review and your reflections on the novel. The opening sentence immediately sets the tone, linking the title to a broader cultural reference and inviting the reader into the world of the book. It also becomes evident at once that the period in which the novel is set resonates personally with you, and that restrained autobiographical touch makes the review all the more engaging.

    I particularly admired how succinctly and effectively you identify Oates’s stylistic strengths. Rather than merely praising her prose, you illustrate its texture through carefully chosen examples of sensory description, alliteration, simile and metaphor. Your review pays close attention to the language itself, which is something many reviews overlook.

    The passage on the landscape is especially perceptive. You recognise that Oates’s descriptions transcend physical beauty and inhabit the emotional landscape of her characters. After quoting the evocative lines about the “nervous slap of waves” and the mingling of pine scent with “sleep, dreams,” your observation, “Even this extract closes with a sense of the tension which is never far from the narrative,” is, to my mind, the finest critical sentence in the review. It captures how beauty and unease coexist throughout the novel.

    I also appreciated your understated honesty in writing, “At times I had to lay it down for a few days rest from the action scenes…”. It conveys the emotional impact of the novel far more effectively than simply describing parts of it as “disturbing.” That personal response tells the reader not just what the book contains, but what it feels like to experience it.

    1. Uma, your eloquent and insightful analysis of my review is an absolute treasure. Thank you so much for your deep understanding.

  8. Derrick, I’ve always admired your book reviews. Do you take notes if you know you’ll be critiquing the work, or do you go back from memory to sight quotes, or to search for writing devices? While I was never subjected to abuse in my family, I’ve been traumatized seeing horrific things inflicted on neighborhood children in my youth. I could never read this book. A tip of the hat for getting through it.

    1. Thank you so much, Alys. I do make notes along the way, but there were many examples this time that I wasn’t prepared to post

    1. It sure was. I’ve never seen a VAR override an on field ref before. Thanks very much, Gary

Leave a comment