In this next essay in his ‘Victorian England’ G. M. Young sensibly points out the difficulty of selecting the greatest of anything, and sets out his personal criteria.
“We are looking for a man who was in or of his age, and who could have been of no other; a man with sympathy to share, and genius to judge, its sentiments and movements; a man not too illustrious or too consummate to be companionable, but one, nevertheless whose ideas too root and are still bearing; whose influence, passing from one fit mind to another, could transmit, and can still impart, the most precious element in Victorian civilisation, its robust and masculine sanity.”
Despite this apparently misogynistic statement, Young, as had many others, seriously considered George Eliot, a woman who felt obliged write with a male pen-name, and who “….had genius of the blend, humorous, observant, didactic, which that age most appreciated; she had raised herself to the head of the literary profession; her gnomic wisdom was a light to thousands who had learnt from her that, in the darkness deepening over all ancient faiths, the star of duty shone clearer than ever.”
“To be typically great, a man must be, as Tennyson was, profoundly in sympathy with the chief preoccupations of his time; and the preoccupations of the Victorian mind, the points to which it swung most constantly and anxiously, were on the one side theological and moral, on the other social.”
Matthew Arnold was also considered. Charles Darwin was dismissed because his work “belongs to the isolated and timeless world of pure scientific speculation…”
Ruskin “….evolved, and forced his world to accept a new set of axioms as the basis of all future political science in England.” “But Ruskin is too fantastic, too childlike, too incoherent, to be typical of an. age which loved solidity and efficiency…..and was always a little dubious and distrustful of genius.”
In nominating Walter Bagehot, Young does “…not assert that [he] was the greatest man alive and working between 1837 and 1901; I am not sure that the statement would mean anything….” “But what was peculiarly his own was the perfect management of all this energy and all these resources. He was well aware of his superiority of intelligence….But he carried it with such genial and ironic delight…..”
_________
This evening we dined on a fusion meal of final left overs of the Chinese takeaway; Jackie’s egg and pepper rice; tempura prawns; and spring rolls; with which we drank the same beverages as yesterday.


Young’s criteria for greatness is quite revealing and limiting.
It is. Thanks very much, Rosaliene
Ah! Like you, Derrick! “…genial and ironic delight…”!
Thank you so much, Ed
It’s interesting who he considered and rejected, as well as who he ended up with.
It is. Actually I didn’t know anything about Bagehot. Thanks very much, Merril
I’m glad I’m not the only one who didn’t know anything about him! 😊
Victorian Britain offers a bewildering abundance of greatness: Darwin, Dickens, George Eliot, Tennyson, Ruskin, Mill, Carlyle, Gladstone and many others. Choosing Bagehot among them tells us nearly as much about G. M. Young’s conception of Victorian greatness as it does about Bagehot himself.
Thank you for the exceptional overview.
Exactly. Thank you very much, Uma
This IS so interesting…the men considered, and why, and then Young’s choice.
Good review, Derrick!
Your fushion meal sounds delicious…we do such a fushion meal a few times a week. YAY for leftovers. 🙂
(((HUGS))) and ❤️❤️
Thank you so much, Carolyn XX
An interesting review about odd choices.
Thank you very much, Anne
Interesting to read his list of who qualifies, who did not and why. Thanks, Derrick.
Much appreciated, Pat
Wonderful analysis, Derrick.
You captured the essence of the Victorian mind, balancing the era’s deep preoccupations with morality and its genuine love for solidity.
Thank you very much, Luisa
You are so very welcome, dear Derrick!
It was my pleasure
I find the clear listing of criteria and considerations valuable in defining for myself “what is Victorian.”
Thanks very much, Crystal
It is so tricky selecting this sort of thing – the people who seemed so notable to a Victorian have met with mixed fortunes through the years. I only come across Bagehot when list of famous Victorians are mentioned, Arnold has faded, Ruskin is slightly suspect and Tennyson is dated. That just leaves us with George Eliot and her eminence seems as great, or greater, now as it was then.
However, none of my modern views have any bearing on who influenced the Victorians . . .
Thanks very much, Quercus
I’m so glad I didn’t live in the male dominated Victorian era.
I’m sure. Thank you very much, Sue
The Victorian mindset is fascinating, etched with brilliance and brutality.
Quite so, Gary. Thanks very much
Interesting choice
Thanks very much, Sheree