Victoria: Political Attitudes

‘Victoria: Political attitudes’ by Frank Hardie is the next essay in the Folio Society’s edition of Victorian England. He presents her as a hot tempered and interfering autocrat who, according to [Lytton] “Strachey…..did not really understand the constitution over which she presided.”

She took different sides in the conflicts between Conservative and Liberal policies; liked Disraeli and detested Gladstone. These factors influenced her judgement and her utterances, both verbal and in writing.

She was opposed to Home Rule for Ireland. She said ‘I would never give way about the Scottish Church which is the real and true stronghold of Protestantism.’ “She was vehemently opposed to Welsh disestablishment.” The Anglican Church in Wales was thus not deprived of its official status until 1919.

“The Queen was much more interested in the army than in the navy. She considered the navy a ‘most distasteful profession….the worst for morals and everything that can be imagined’ (Roger Fulford)”

“in 1895 she was ‘horrified at the motion for payment of MPs being carried’ (Letter)”

She was concerned not to over-tax the working class, e.g. funding the Boer War; “mildly interested in working class housing”, but not generally “interested in Disraeli’s social legislation, sometimes thought to be his greatest achievement.”

Despite her own position “she was a passionate opponent of women’s rights.”

“Her political role from 1868 to 1901 was……distinctly similar to that of the House of Lords at the same time, ‘a vigilant and destructive opposition to the programmes of all Liberal Governments’……As Dilke put it ‘The Queen does interfere constantly; more, however, where Liberal Ministers are in power than when she has a Conservative Cabinet, because on the whole the Conservatives do what she likes, as she is a Conservative, whereas the Liberals are continually doing, and indeed exist for the purpose of doing, the things that she does not like.’ (A.L. Rowse)”

“The Queen objected strongly to something she disapproved of being announced in her name…” She can’t have understood the purpose of the Queen’s Speech as presenting the intentions of her Parliament.

Her comments on the outcome of successive elections display her Conservatism, despite her regarding herself as Liberal.

Hardie has managed to throw some light on all this confusion.

James Luke battled with wind and rain today in efforts to continue with the outside carpentry. He hopes to complete much more tomorrow.

This evening I dined on what I couldn’t eat yesterday from the chicken jalfrezi meal topped up with a poached egg and a vegetable samosa, while Jackie enjoyed poached eggs on toast. She drank more of the Juicy rosé and I finished the Fleurie.

31 comments

  1. I have never heard this information about the Queen. It’s fascinating. The part about not supporting women’s rights makes me wonder if she simply did not understand how important rights are, when you are born with them.

    1. Also, I will forever remember the time when I was in Bath, and spotted a carving of her on high, looking out over the street near the Pulteney Bridge. Locals walking past me looked up to see what I was looking at and exclaimed, “It’s VICKY!” ha ha ha

  2. She was certainly a bundle of attitudes and emotions. It’s probably not fair to expect her to be more enlightened than she was, given her class and the times. Still, there were Victorians who had broader minds that allowed them to have more sympathy and empathy. But perhaps they were the exception rather than the rule. What do you think?

    1. You are right about expectations, Laurie. Her mother was uncaring to her and her grief dominated her emotional life drawing her to more likeable men than Gladstone. Thanks very much

  3. She certainly does not come off well here. I suspect she was not given the best education, but it seems she also did not have the curiosity to seek out more knowledge.

  4. Good review of this essay on Queen Victoria!
    I learned some things about her that I did not know.
    Like most humans, she was complex…and, also, quite interesting.
    Thanks for sharing this with us, Derrick!
    (((HUGS))) for Jackie and you!! ❤️❤️

  5. A wonderfully compact portrait of Victoria: formidable, opinionated and full of contradictions. I particularly enjoyed the irony of a Queen fiercely opposed to women’s rights, and a staunch Conservative who apparently thought herself a Liberal!

Leave a comment