Disraeli and Gladstone

Robert Norman William Blake was a Conservative historian. He is best known for his 1966 biography of Benjamin Disraeli, 1st Earl of Beaconsfield, and for The Conservative Party from Peel to Churchill, which grew out of his 1968 Ford lectures. He was created a life peer in 1971 as Baron Blake of Braydeston. (https://rsliterature.org/fellows/lord-blake/#:~:text=Robert%20Norman%20William%20Blake%20was,of%20his%201968%20Ford%20lectures.)

It is Lord Blake who wrote this next essay in The Folio Society volume of ‘Victorian England’. ‘Disraeli and Gladstone’ the two great Victorian rival statesmen, unlike what we are told about today’s opposing parliamentarians who can be friends outside the House, truly loathed each other.

“Disraeli oscillated between Victoria’s view that Gladstone was insane and the more common Tory theory that he was a monstrous hypocrite.”

“… self-mortification, the consciousness of sin, the desire to make amends by bringing the highest moral principles into the political career which [Gladstone] always regarded as second best to the Church were among his principal springs of action.” “[Disraeli’s] aim was above all to be someone to get to the top…. One [reason] was his sense of being an outsider, an alien, a person who did not belong…. The other is his unhappy relationship with his mother who regarded him as ‘a clever boy but no genius’….. Again and again through Disraeli’s sophistication, his poses, his play-acting, one senses a little boy crying out ‘look at me’ to an unreceptive sceptical mamma ‘troubled about many things’, not unkind or hostile, but not prepared to adore.”

“….. many people distrusted Disraeli. There was something highly provocative about him, a brazenness, a sarcastic turn of phrase, an insolence, a readiness to discard inconvenient pledges, and a refusal to cover up that process with normal politicians’ linguistic cotton wool….”

“Gladstone had an intensity, a fervour, a conviction of absolute right and wrong…..” “At times one feels that Disraeli’s antipathy to Gladstone – and Gladstone’s to Disraeli – was …. caused …. rather by their whole approach to politics, their way of thinking, their political style. What Disraeli disliked was the bringing of morality and religion into politics – to him an essentially practical business. By the same token Gladstone deplored the cynical amorality of his old enemy.”

“One could probably say of them as parliamentarians that the honours were even. As ministers no. The most ardent admirer of Disraeli must concede that Gladstone was more thorough, more knowledgeable, more energetic, better briefed…”

“Most people, basing themselves on his novels and other dicta, would regard Disraeli as the more cosmopolitan and cultivated of the two. In fact it was Gladstone. He travelled much more than Disraeli. In addition to a first-class knowledge of the classics, he was at home in French, Italian and German. He was very widely read….and he conducted a vast correspondence with theologians and scholars all over Europe. “Disraeli….. was abroad very little… His classical knowledge had very shaky foundations, though he could put up a good show…..”

Disraeli was the more uncomfortable in the company of men, and Gladstone equally comfortable with either sex. Both made happy, lasting, marriages.

Lord Blake sums up with “Perhaps we should not try to make comparisons between them at all. Perhaps we should end as we began, with Lord Granville – ‘Lord Beaconsfield and Mr Gladstone are men of extraordinary ability’ – and leave it at that.”

____________

This evening we dined on Cajan style pork chops with Jackie’s savoury rice and our own runner beans, with which we each drank the same wines as yesterday.

22 comments

  1. I find it interesting and compelling to imagine that they despised each other as a result of their different political styles. I am imagining that they didn’t understand each other’s perspective enough to respect them. I am always a fan of this kind of book, though not “fun” for me to read, I remain fascinated by powerful people’s lives, and politics especially.

  2. Thank you for this enlightening piece. What I especially enjoyed in Blake’s account is his eye for the human being behind the statesman. The little boy in Disraeli still crying “look at me” to an unimpressed mother is wonderfully perceptive, whether or not one accepts the psychology completely. And “normal politicians’ linguistic cotton wool” is delicious. By the end, these are no longer two marble Victorian figures glaring at one another across history, but two extraordinarily gifted, deeply incompatible men. Their mutual loathing almost begins to seem inevitable.

  3. All I know of the two men is from watching ‘Victoria’, where, a bit like Queen Victoria, I fell for Disraeli and dismissed Gladstone. 😀

Leave a comment