England In The Later Middle Ages

This book, by M.H. Keen is the fourth in The Folio Society’s twelve volume History of England.

“…. in 1294 another major war had commenced, with France; this is why the ‘auld alliance’, of France and Scotland against England, came into being at this point in the 1290s. From then onwards, with only short intervals, England was to remain at war with Scotland or France, or both, until the end of the medieval period.” Keen describes the difficulties of paying for this by way of taxes, loans, and indenture of the magnates in the period known as ‘bastard feudalism’.

From 1295 until the time of his death in 1307 Edward I was beset by unrest and wars in Wales, Scotland, Flanders, and Gascony. In 1314 “Robert king of Scots met Edward II’s army at Bannockburn and inflicted on it a crushing defeat….. The battle did not end the war which was to last through the rest of Edward’s reign.”

“On the brink of civil war Earl Thomas of Lancaster led a march against King Edward II…. At Boroughbridge in Yorkshire, on 16 March 1322…… Lancaster…. and others surrendered to Sir Andrew [Harclay] who turned them over to King Edward. On 22 March, after a summary trial, Lancaster was executed at Pontefract. Mowbray, Clifford [and others] were also condemned to death….. This was the first occasion on which summary sentences of death and forfeiture for high treason were passed on peers of the realm in England. It was an ominous precedent.”

“Ten years of perpetual civil insecurity had strained control at the local level to the point of breakdown. Lawlessness was rife until 1320s; bands of armed men roamed at large and made a business of robbery.”

During these two reigns “Parliament was an action not a body of people – thus it was largely a collection of important barons summoned by the king to decide on specific matters rather than an elected body as we have today.”

Conflict with Scots at the beginning of King Edward III’s reign “can be regarded as a kind of prelude to the much more important war of France, which began in 1337.” “[Edward]’s riposte to Philip [VI]’s confiscation of Gascony was to claim that he, not Philip was the rightful king of France….. This deliberate reopening of the question of the French succession made it quite clear that Edward did not intend to compromise in any way on the issues of Aquitaine or Scotland.”

The “first phase of the war, from 1338 to 1360, may be further subdivided into three periods. The first of these witnessed, in the years 1337 to 1341, the attempt of Edward III to bring together a great coalition against the Valois, and its failure. The second saw new fronts opened up on French soil, in Brittany and Normandy, and ended with the capture by the English of the port of Calais in Picardy in 1348. The third period saw the great English victory at Poitiers, where King John of France was taken prisoner, and the campaigning which drew to a close when the peace was agreed at Brétigny.”

“When the king was abroad, he kept in constant touch with his councillors, and sent home from time to time reports of his doings, which were to be read out in fairs and markets and other public places.”

“It was after the great tournament at Windsor in 1344 that Edward laid the foundations for what was to become his Order of the Garter. It was to be a fellowship of knights, bound together as companions by their oaths to aid and support one another and the sovereign of the order, and was modelled on the fellowship of knights of Arthur’s round table. The formal institution of the order dates from 1348, following the famous scene at a ball held at Calais when the Countess of Salisbury dropped her garter, and the king, who was in love with her, picked it up and bound it on his knee, afterwards adopting it as the badge of his order.”

“To sum up, Edward III succeeded impressively in restoring among his subjects respect for the English monarchy which the disasters of Edward II’s reign had lowered perilously. But he did so at the cost of royal power and prerogative, not by reasserting them.”

“In June 1348 the Black Death, the great pandemic of bubonic plague which had originated in Asia, reached England.” Further major outbreaks occurred over most of the rest of the century. “Plague had become endemic, an inescapable factor of the medieval existence…. there was a dramatic contraction of the population.” “Scarcity of labour was a constant of economic conditions in the period after the plagues.”

Thus the price of labour increased and there was greater movement of population seeking work.

“Wool was easily the most important item of export” and developed into that of finished cloth.

“The period from the end of the thirteenth to the end of the fifteenth century was a very important one in the history of the relations of Church and State in England. It witnessed developments whose cumulative consequence was to establish by gradual degrees an effective royal supremacy in the English Church long before that supremacy was legally enforced by Henry VIII.” “The kings took advantage of the groundswell of popular feeling in the background, anti-alien, anti-papal and anti-clerical; they did not create it. If the English Church was becoming recognisably a national church in the centuries before the Reformation it was because the people at large… wished it to do so, rather than as a result of conscious and premeditated royal policy,” combined with lack of spiritual leadership from the established church.

“For nearly nine years after the Treaty of Brétigny England and France were nominally at peace…. When in 1369 the Hundred Years war re-opened as a result of deliberate provocation on the French side, [England was] ill-prepared.” “The French had won veritable success in the years from 1369 to 1375 but by the end of them were beginning to feel the strain…[and] were glad of a truce.”

“The Peasants’ Revolt of 1381 was the climax of a crisis of confidence in government, which was largely generated by failures in the war….. Taxation was heavier and more sustained than it had been at any time since the 1340s.” Two poll taxes were the blue touch paper for the nationwide revolt.

“They chose as chief Wat Tyler…. The other important Kentish leader was John Ball, the revolutionary hedge priest whose catch words have gone down in history: When Adam delved and Eve span Who was then the gentleman?”

With great courage and diplomacy the fourteen year old King Richard II rode out to meet the revolters and negotiate an ending.

In 1399 Henry Bolingbroke led a group of dissatisfied magnates in conflict with royal autocracy against an inadequately prepared Richard who was forced to abdicate leaving the throne available to Henry IV.

“The series of great rebellions in the first part ofHenry IV’s reign throws a very significant light on the revolution of 1399. They reveal how shaky the foundations of the Lancastrian succession were.”

In presenting his views on a cross section of society of the times Keen avails himself of the characters in Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, and the three influential self-made men he describes the most widely known is Richard Whittington who “over a period of more than twenty years… was one of the most significant individual lenders to the Crown.”

Henry V made it clear on his accession in 1413 that his “intention [was] to consolidate loyalty around the throne and be done with it.” He reopened efforts to claim the French crown. By force of arms, by diplomacy, and by driving conflict between various French nobles he achieved mastery of large parts of Normandy and Aquitaine.

The most well known military victory was that of Agincourt in 1415. After Agincourt, the question of the right of the Lancastrian dynasty to sit upon the English throne ceased to be an issue in English politics. This victory “placed him in a very favourable bargaining position in regard to the parties in France.” Then came Joan of Arc who turned the tide in favour of her country, was betrayed and sold to the English who burned her as a heretic. Her tale is delightfully told in

Mismanagement, self interest and conflicts between those counselling King Henry VI before and after his coming of age in 1437 brought about collapse of government resulting in Jack Cade’s rebellion in 1450 and “brought old discords that were latent to the surface of English politics and sowed the seeds of new ones. These together gave rise to the struggle which we call The Wars of The Roses.” “Between 1461 and 1485 four kings sat upon the throne of England. All four were driven from the throne by force, one (Henry VI) twice, one (Edward IV) only temporarily,” [and] Edward IV”.

The usurpation of 1483 and alleged murder of the boy who would have been Edward V and his younger brother has provoked a national controversy lasting more than half a millennium. This has been the subject of

‘There’s No Need For That To Be In The Road’

Being a firm adherent of the adage attached to Robert the Bruce: ‘If at first you don’t succeed, try, try, try again’, I set off this morning in search of Dave’s lakes which I had failed to find yesterday.  For those who don’t know the story, King Robert I of Scotland, their fourteenth century monarch who fought against England, wasn’t doing very well.  He was doing so badly in fact that he sought refuge in a cave.  Whilst sitting there, pondering his next move, he watched a spider struggling to attach the thread of its web to the wall.  Back and forth, up and down, went the arachnid in its attempt to secure its fly trap. Eventually the apparently hopeless task was achieved.  Inspired by this, King Robert continued his guerrilla warfare until, at Bannockburn in 1314, a resounding victory secured independent sovereignty for his nation. What is good for a spider and a king is good enough for me.  This time I took a map and continued on the path the other side of Forest Road past Andrew’s Mare car park.  There I was given encouragement by the number of dog walkers coming to and going from their vehicles.  They must be travelling somewhere for pet frolics.  I fell in with a couple who confirmed that I was headed in the right direction.  The woman, identifying her dogs for my benefit, described them rather uncomplimentarily as ‘idiot Saluki crosses’.  Salukis in LakeApparently all the exercise they take is chasing each other after sticks thrown into the large lake. Salukis After watching the canine cavorting for I while, and feeling somewhat satisfied to have got this far without mishap, I studied my Ordnance Survey map very hard, and decided I would attempt to descend to Acres Down before returning via Newtown. Heathland FootpathI selected my path and strode across the heath. Ditch Had I paid a little more attention to the contour lines I would have realised that the one I had chosen descended steeply to a ford and rose equally as steeply on the other side.  Ascending the flinty gravel surface put me in mind of the very scary unstable scree that had made me cop out of the final push up Cumbria’s Scap Fell many years ago.  Anyone who has a similar phobia of heights will know that it becomes much worse when children are involved.  On this occasion, Louisa, then very young, had slipped on the loose stones.  That was enough to paralyse me.  Louisa, with her far more intrepid mother, reached the top.  I didn’t.  This was, however, a much gentler slope and not so far above sea level. A stream was forded just after a stone memorial Dave had told me I would pass yesterday.Murray's memorial  But, as we know, I was nowhere near it then.  Finding Murray’s memorial filled me with confidence and a certain smug satisfaction. Admiral Murray was killed whilst hunting on Backley Plain on 17th September 1901.  If you ask me, Sir Walter Tyrrell has a lot to answer for.  It was he who, allegedly accidentally, shot William Rufus not far away, thus setting an unfortunate precedent.  The story is told in photographs of the Rufus Stone posted on 19th November last year.  That memorial is about three or four miles away on the other side of the A31. Seeking further information about Admiral Murray and his manner of passing all I could find was a notice in the New Zealand Herald of 23rd November 1901 stating that he had been killed in the New Forest and had had a distinguished naval career.  This may or may not suggest he was a New Zealander.  Our antipodean friends seem to be a little short of pressworthy material, judging by The National, whose quiz Jackie and her workmates were encouraged to attempt each week by  her native colleague Brent. She still regularly attempts this puzzle. Murray's PassageAt the top of the slope is that rare thing, a signpost, leading to Murray’s Passage.  Not much good to anyone approaching it, as I did, from the lakes. Skirting Stonard Wood, as the map told me, I could go for broke and turn right down to Acres Down just to prove I could do it, or I could quit whilst I was ahead and aim for Newtown.  I chose the latter.  Once I correctly turned left the footpaths seemed to have been deliberately arranged in a series of celtic knots just to confuse me. Heathland footpath divides Had I always taken the right fork I would have arrived at my intended point on the Forest Road, the crossroads leading to Acres Down and Newtown.  I did sometimes.  But not always. When I noticed a cairn I had passed yesterday I didn’t know whether to be pleased or not.  CairnThis could either mean everything had gone horribly wrong or I was on the right track.  As confirmed by a pair of familiar rowan trees a bit further along, it was a bit of both.  I did emerge more or less on Forest Road, but not at my targeted crossroads.  I arrived at the Forestry Commission gate at the path to the lakes that I had gone through too early yesterday, about fifty or sixty yards from the A31. Well, I wasn’t going back along the road to the Newtown crossroads, so I retraced my steps alongside the major road, continuing rather precariously after the footpath petered out by Little Chef.  This earned me a ship’s foghorn blast from a huge lorry.  I think that was rather unnecessary.  After all, the traffic was nowhere near as fast as usual, when the slipstream blows you off your feet, and I was wading through brambles at the time.  The speed restriction was because of an accident that had slowed things up.  An ambulance crew in  a lay-by were checking out two unhurt young Asians gazing wistfully at the bashed-in offside front wing of their sprauncy red car.  Don’t ask me what make it was.  Be satisfied that I even noticed the colour.  One medic emerged from some bushes carrying what must once have been a bright new, red, bumper.  ‘There’s no need for that to be in the road’, he said to me. Unbeknown to me Helen and Bill had passed me on the A31 on their way to Castle Malwood Lodge.  They drew level with me as I walked down Upper Drive.  This time they offered me a lift.  I declined, reasoning that I could probably make it across our lawn.  As we all walked into our flat together Jackie informed me that she had just sent me a text asking if I wanted a lift.  She knew that, after yesterday, there was no way I would ask for one, yet it was getting a little late.  Had that come earlier I could have done with it.  My left calf is complaining somewhat of overwork. My one-time-sister-and-brother-in-law stayed for a pleasant conversation about Lincoln and its environs, where they had been on holiday and once lived, and which I know quite well. This evening Jackie and I dined on her  marvellous mixed meat stew with no apparent trace of sausage, followed by gooseberry and rhubarb crumble and custard.