England In The Later Middle Ages

This book, by M.H. Keen is the fourth in The Folio Society’s twelve volume History of England.

“…. in 1294 another major war had commenced, with France; this is why the ‘auld alliance’, of France and Scotland against England, came into being at this point in the 1290s. From then onwards, with only short intervals, England was to remain at war with Scotland or France, or both, until the end of the medieval period.” Keen describes the difficulties of paying for this by way of taxes, loans, and indenture of the magnates in the period known as ‘bastard feudalism’.

From 1295 until the time of his death in 1307 Edward I was beset by unrest and wars in Wales, Scotland, Flanders, and Gascony. In 1314 “Robert king of Scots met Edward II’s army at Bannockburn and inflicted on it a crushing defeat….. The battle did not end the war which was to last through the rest of Edward’s reign.”

“On the brink of civil war Earl Thomas of Lancaster led a march against King Edward II…. At Boroughbridge in Yorkshire, on 16 March 1322…… Lancaster…. and others surrendered to Sir Andrew [Harclay] who turned them over to King Edward. On 22 March, after a summary trial, Lancaster was executed at Pontefract. Mowbray, Clifford [and others] were also condemned to death….. This was the first occasion on which summary sentences of death and forfeiture for high treason were passed on peers of the realm in England. It was an ominous precedent.”

“Ten years of perpetual civil insecurity had strained control at the local level to the point of breakdown. Lawlessness was rife until 1320s; bands of armed men roamed at large and made a business of robbery.”

During these two reigns “Parliament was an action not a body of people – thus it was largely a collection of important barons summoned by the king to decide on specific matters rather than an elected body as we have today.”

Conflict with Scots at the beginning of King Edward III’s reign “can be regarded as a kind of prelude to the much more important war of France, which began in 1337.” “[Edward]’s riposte to Philip [VI]’s confiscation of Gascony was to claim that he, not Philip was the rightful king of France….. This deliberate reopening of the question of the French succession made it quite clear that Edward did not intend to compromise in any way on the issues of Aquitaine or Scotland.”

The “first phase of the war, from 1338 to 1360, may be further subdivided into three periods. The first of these witnessed, in the years 1337 to 1341, the attempt of Edward III to bring together a great coalition against the Valois, and its failure. The second saw new fronts opened up on French soil, in Brittany and Normandy, and ended with the capture by the English of the port of Calais in Picardy in 1348. The third period saw the great English victory at Poitiers, where King John of France was taken prisoner, and the campaigning which drew to a close when the peace was agreed at Brétigny.”

“When the king was abroad, he kept in constant touch with his councillors, and sent home from time to time reports of his doings, which were to be read out in fairs and markets and other public places.”

“It was after the great tournament at Windsor in 1344 that Edward laid the foundations for what was to become his Order of the Garter. It was to be a fellowship of knights, bound together as companions by their oaths to aid and support one another and the sovereign of the order, and was modelled on the fellowship of knights of Arthur’s round table. The formal institution of the order dates from 1348, following the famous scene at a ball held at Calais when the Countess of Salisbury dropped her garter, and the king, who was in love with her, picked it up and bound it on his knee, afterwards adopting it as the badge of his order.”

“To sum up, Edward III succeeded impressively in restoring among his subjects respect for the English monarchy which the disasters of Edward II’s reign had lowered perilously. But he did so at the cost of royal power and prerogative, not by reasserting them.”

“In June 1348 the Black Death, the great pandemic of bubonic plague which had originated in Asia, reached England.” Further major outbreaks occurred over most of the rest of the century. “Plague had become endemic, an inescapable factor of the medieval existence…. there was a dramatic contraction of the population.” “Scarcity of labour was a constant of economic conditions in the period after the plagues.”

Thus the price of labour increased and there was greater movement of population seeking work.

“Wool was easily the most important item of export” and developed into that of finished cloth.

“The period from the end of the thirteenth to the end of the fifteenth century was a very important one in the history of the relations of Church and State in England. It witnessed developments whose cumulative consequence was to establish by gradual degrees an effective royal supremacy in the English Church long before that supremacy was legally enforced by Henry VIII.” “The kings took advantage of the groundswell of popular feeling in the background, anti-alien, anti-papal and anti-clerical; they did not create it. If the English Church was becoming recognisably a national church in the centuries before the Reformation it was because the people at large… wished it to do so, rather than as a result of conscious and premeditated royal policy,” combined with lack of spiritual leadership from the established church.

“For nearly nine years after the Treaty of Brétigny England and France were nominally at peace…. When in 1369 the Hundred Years war re-opened as a result of deliberate provocation on the French side, [England was] ill-prepared.” “The French had won veritable success in the years from 1369 to 1375 but by the end of them were beginning to feel the strain…[and] were glad of a truce.”

“The Peasants’ Revolt of 1381 was the climax of a crisis of confidence in government, which was largely generated by failures in the war….. Taxation was heavier and more sustained than it had been at any time since the 1340s.” Two poll taxes were the blue touch paper for the nationwide revolt.

“They chose as chief Wat Tyler…. The other important Kentish leader was John Ball, the revolutionary hedge priest whose catch words have gone down in history: When Adam delved and Eve span Who was then the gentleman?”

With great courage and diplomacy the fourteen year old King Richard II rode out to meet the revolters and negotiate an ending.

In 1399 Henry Bolingbroke led a group of dissatisfied magnates in conflict with royal autocracy against an inadequately prepared Richard who was forced to abdicate leaving the throne available to Henry IV.

“The series of great rebellions in the first part ofHenry IV’s reign throws a very significant light on the revolution of 1399. They reveal how shaky the foundations of the Lancastrian succession were.”

In presenting his views on a cross section of society of the times Keen avails himself of the characters in Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, and the three influential self-made men he describes the most widely known is Richard Whittington who “over a period of more than twenty years… was one of the most significant individual lenders to the Crown.”

Henry V made it clear on his accession in 1413 that his “intention [was] to consolidate loyalty around the throne and be done with it.” He reopened efforts to claim the French crown. By force of arms, by diplomacy, and by driving conflict between various French nobles he achieved mastery of large parts of Normandy and Aquitaine.

The most well known military victory was that of Agincourt in 1415. After Agincourt, the question of the right of the Lancastrian dynasty to sit upon the English throne ceased to be an issue in English politics. This victory “placed him in a very favourable bargaining position in regard to the parties in France.” Then came Joan of Arc who turned the tide in favour of her country, was betrayed and sold to the English who burned her as a heretic. Her tale is delightfully told in

Mismanagement, self interest and conflicts between those counselling King Henry VI before and after his coming of age in 1437 brought about collapse of government resulting in Jack Cade’s rebellion in 1450 and “brought old discords that were latent to the surface of English politics and sowed the seeds of new ones. These together gave rise to the struggle which we call The Wars of The Roses.” “Between 1461 and 1485 four kings sat upon the throne of England. All four were driven from the throne by force, one (Henry VI) twice, one (Edward IV) only temporarily,” [and] Edward IV”.

The usurpation of 1483 and alleged murder of the boy who would have been Edward V and his younger brother has provoked a national controversy lasting more than half a millennium. This has been the subject of

Skullduggery

My iPhotos collection of photographs received no adjustment when today I retained the one photograph from

but I have deleted the single one from

and the two from

A few years ago Jackie planted some lilies in the Pond Bed. None came to fruition. Apparently small rodents feast on the bulbs.

Today she disinterred the remains of the culprit, and offered me my blog post title.

This afternoon I read Charles Ross’s lengthy introduction to his history ‘Richard III’, which is essentially an examination of the differing opinions on the nature of the king featured in https://derrickjknight.com/2025/01/07/richard-and-the-princes/

I will say more about this balanced introduction when I have read and review the history which may be relevant to my previous post.

This evening we dined on roast duck with crispy skin; baby boiled potatoes, cauliflower, its chopped leaves, broccoli, and carrots, with tasty gravy. I drank more of the Kimbao.

Richard And The Princes

Between dinner and bed we generally watch TV, but, as I prefer to close my blog posts with a culinary note, perhaps rather earlier than Samuel Pepys’s “and so to bed”, I don’t normally include what we have viewed.

I am making an exception to cover two programmes we enjoyed over the last couple of evenings with Becky at her recommendation.

King Richard III, England’s last Plantagenet monarch, was killed at the Battle of Bosworth in 1485 and for half a millennium his body was missing, hence the title of the film we watched two nights ago – “The Lost King”, which focusses on the search for the remains and their discovery under a car park in Leicester, some 12 miles from Bosworth Field.

Despite withdrawal of financial support by other funders, Philippa Langley, the amateur historian instigating the search, having succeeded in gaining the necessary resources, persisted and unearthed

the bones that DNA confirmed were those of the king. The film focussed on Ms Langley’s efforts and her relationship with the University of Leicester. Richard III had, for more than 500 years, been regarded by many as an evil usurper, influenced by portrayals from William Shakespeare and Sir Thomas More. Having now been accepted as a rightful monarch he received a more dignified reinterment on 26th March 2015 at Leicester Cathedral.

In response to his portrayal in the film, “Richard Taylor, a former deputy registrar at the University of Leicester, is suing [writer Steve] Coogan, the production company Baby Cow and the distributors Pathe.

“He claims the 2022 movie The Lost King shows his character, played by Lee Ingleby, behaving in an “abominable way” towards the amateur historian Philippa Langley, played by Sally Hawkins, who spearheaded the dig.

“Taylor claims the film shows him taking credit for himself and the university that was rightfully Langley’s for the 2012 discovery of Richard III’s remains in a Leicester car park more than 500 years after the king’s death.

“[High Court Judge] Lewis’s ruling after a preliminary hearing means that the case can proceed to a full trial where Coogan, Baby Cow and Pathe will have to defend the defamatory portrayal.” https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jun/14/steve-coogan-the-lost-king-defamation-claim

Moving on almost 200 years since the death of Richard III, “on 17th July 1674, two skeletons were discovered inside the Tower of London. Many believed they were the Princes in the Tower – 12-year-old Edward V and 9-year-old Richard, Duke of York.

“The boys disappeared in 1483 during the Wars of the Roses, creating one of the biggest mysteries in British history. Then, nearly 200 years after they vanished, Charles II re-interred the two skeletons from the Tower in their names at Westminster Abbey.

.”The identity of the children discovered at the Tower of London in 1674 may never be known. Similarly, the fate of the Princes in the Tower may forever lie beyond our understanding. However, this should not deter us from asking questions and embarking on new research. Research is a journey we learn from even if we don’t arrive at our anticipated destination.” (Charles Farris Public Historian for the History of the Monarchy Historic Royal Palaces)

Philippa Langley, however, was convinced that Richard III, long blamed for the believed murder of his two nephews, was innocent, and that the children had survived their time in the tower to make their own attempts to secure the monarchy as first Lambert Simnel (Edward V) and later Perkin Warbeck (Richard, Duke of York). Thus she collaborated with Rob Rinder, an investigative lawyer to research the evidence in Channel 4’s documentary ‘The Princes in the Tower: The New Evidence’. They present a compelling case for the boys having survived to in turn lead attempted invasions against the incumbent king. Neither of these succeeded.

As well produced as was this programme, without DNA evidence from the boys’ bones I cannot be convinced that the nephews were even murdered. I think it was Philippa who said that these particular remains could only be DNA tested with Royal permission which had been denied by Queen Elizabeth II because she believed they should be allowed to rest in peace. Of course this procedure could only clarify whether or not they were the children concerned.

Naturally the conclusions of Langley and Rinder have been challenged by numerous establishment historians, which leaves us with the truth of the final paragraph of the extracts from Charles Farris quoted above.

Moving on even further to this afternoon, Becky and Ian returned to their own home and Jackie and I took a forest drive

when the sun was lowering in advance of its setting.

There were still many pools on the roads but none remained impassable.

The dampness had kept the woodland brightly mossy;

skeletal trees swept skies;

and ponies quietly foraged.

This evening we dined on tempura prawns on a bed of Jackie’s savoury rice, with which she drank Diet Coke and I finished the Malbec.

A Night At The Globe

I began the day by photographing the corner of the garden in which the new fernery is located, so that Danni can see where it is.

Jackie then drove us back to Morden in readiness for a visit to The Globe Theatre this evening.  Sam and Holly had given me two tickets for Richard III for my birthday.  Disaster then struck.  I had left the lead for transferring photos from my camera to my laptop at The Firs.  I therefore walked to Jessops at Colliers Wood and back, to try to purchase a new connection.  They do not sell them, but sold me a Multi Card Reader.  Since I have been using a card reader system at Elizabeth’s, I thought this would be fine.

In the precincts of Abbey Mills Centre by the river Wandle, a heron was offering suggestions to a puzzler.

Walking back through Morden at school finishing time, I was reminded that I had left rural Hampshire for the end of the Northern Line, gateway to the South, as Peter Sellers put it when chanting of Balham.  I had to weave my way through milling schoolchildren, taking care to dodge their icecreams and sticky sweets; make way for mothers pushing buggies; elude shoppers with wheelie bags, endangering my sandalled feet; and avoid motorised vehicles for people with disabilities.  I was back on familiar territory.

Settling down with my laptop I followed the meagre instructions which came with the reader.  Nothing was happening.  I could not download my pictures.  I telephoned Jessops, whose representative said it sounded as if the reader was faulty, and advised me to reboot my laptop and if it still didn’t work return to the store.  It didn’t, so I will return to Jessops in the morning and hope to be able to add photographs to this post.

This evening we travelled by underground to Sam Wanamaker’s gift to the world.  Our mode of changing trains at Kennington is best described in Jackie’s words.  As we approached a train about to leave for Waterloo she reports that I flung myself into the closing gap in the doors and left her standing on the platform.  I turned, held my hand up to the window and raised one finger.  This was to indicate that Waterloo was one stop away.  Contemplating the amused glances of the other passengers, I felt grateful that it wasn’t two stations away.

Some twenty eight years earlier I had been taking Sam and Louisa on the underground for a trip somewhere or other.  Sam was walking beside his sister in her pushchair.  He trotted into the train just as the doors were closing.  Having just taken Louisa out of it, I quickly shoved the puschair into the gap.  The doors simply pushed the wheeled vehicle out of their way.  This time it was Louisa and me left on the platform.  I found a station employee.  He rang down the line.  Two young men on the train who had seen what had happened escorted Sam off the train at the next station.  Louisa and I followed on, and left, the next train at the same station.  A perfectly happy Sam, munching chocolate, was resting in the arms of a huge London Transport man.  Panic over.

Walking along Blackfriars Road Jackie spotted, through a gap in the streetscape, The Shard, hailed as Western Europe’s tallest building.  Sun reflected from this edifice causes the blinds to be drawn in her office on the eleventh floor of Morden’s Civic Centre.  The view of the skyline we enjoyed as we walked along the Thames to the theatre can clearly be seen from that same office window.

We had a meal of meze at The Real Greek, a couple of doors away from The Globe.  This was so good we wished we had had more time.  Our only complaints might have been that the small tables were rather cramped together, and someone had taken a bite out of the bowl in which my excellent beetroot salad was served.  Jackie drank Mythos, a Greek beer she enjoyed.  I was less adventurous and sampled Kronenbourg.

The Globe is a replica of Shakespeare’s famous original.  In The Bard’s day those who could afford them sat on hard wooden benches under a thatched roof.  Those who couldn’t, known as groundlings, stood in the central enclosure, open to the elements.  So it is today.

Neither of us knew the play and we were therefore surprised at its comic nature. The theatre was jam-packed with spectators, and we had to force our way through the groundlings to reach our bench, which was fully occupied.  The play having just begun, we stood silently on the stairs until a steward approached, moved another couple out of our places, and, equally silently, ushered us in.  Almost polished away by the many bums on these seats, our numbers were just discernible.  This splendid production held our struggling attention until a wave of activity in the central open area, punctuated by the patter of raindrops, rendered what was happening on stage inaudible.  The cast soldiered manfully on.  I say ‘manfully’ because, as an authentic rendition of Shakespearean times, women’s roles were being played by men.  Suddenly the activity in the pit became frenzied.  The downpour drummed on the roof.  The lighting illuminated vertical sheets of rain.  Torrents bounced off hastily donned hoods and scarves.  Shirts and blouses of those who had come unprepared became transparent second skins.  Hair was plastered to scalps, and rivulets ran down necks.  Some who had brought umbrellas were told to close them.  A few who sat on the stairs we had vacated were instructed to leave and stand in the rain because they were blocking an emergency exit.  Staff, and the occasional fortunate child, were issued with clingfilm wrappers by a young woman circulating among the rapidly diminishing throng of saturated, unsheltered, spectators.  Whilst this continued the cast strutted their stuff on stage.  I am sure they must be quite accustomed to such interruptions.  After all, Shakespeare’s groundlings made an awful din.  It will, however, be apparent from the attention I paid to all this going on in front of me that I had lost the plot.  So had Jackie.

P.S. Dated 21st January 2014. Roger Lloyd-Pack, who was speaking as the Duke of Buckingham through the worst of the din, died a week ago. A splendid actor, may he rest in peace.