Excellent Women

We watched leaves and petals flying past our windows as continuing rain accompanied the relentless winds of the last few days.

Needing a little break from the challenges of English History I am pleased that Marina of M. L. Kappa, in a recent post focussed on her admiration of Barbara Pym, thus prompting me to reread

of which this is the Title Page and Frontispiece.

First published in 1952 the book reflects the lives of adults living in postwar London when rationing still kept clothes and comestibles in short supply and difficult to obtain. Although the writer does not make this point, potential husbands, casualties of the Second World War, were also in short supply, thus making a generation of women widows; bearers of engagement rings, no wedding bands, and never-opened bottom drawers.

The future for many was bleak, as it was for Miss Mildred Lathbury. “When my parents died within two years of each other, I was left with a small income of my own, an assortment of furniture, but no home….I worked at the Censorship, for which, very fortunately, no high qualifications appeared to be necessary, apart from patience, discretion, and a slight tendency towards eccentricity.”

The humour apparent throughout the novel is generally sad and often self-disparaging, ” ‘Of course not,’ I said, rather primly, I am afraid’ “

Pym’s language is tight, yet eloquent. “There was a whirring of wings and a crowd of pigeons swooped down onto the flat piece of roof outside the window.” She has an excellent ability for description, often subtly displaying alliteration, awareness of several senses and otherwise unspoken thoughts. “The jingle of the little beaded cover against the milk jug reminded me of Dora and her giggles, her dogmatic opinions and the way she took offence so easily.”

“Excellent women” is a phrase often appearing in the book relating to those, like Mildred, who spend their lives doing good works; caring for others rather than themselves; and making sure always to say the right, never the wrong thing. “It was not the excellent women who got married but people like Allegra Gray, who was no good at sewing, and Helena Napier, who left all the washing up.” When refusing an invitation, ” ‘That’s very kind of you,’ [Mildred] said, speaking slowly to gain time…..” This makes her very indecisive, “I might ask her In to coffee sometime but hesitated about it because I did not quite know how to convey the impression that it was not, of course, to become a regular thing.” “I stood awkwardly, not knowing what to say, I, who had always prided myself on being able to make suitable conversation on all occasions. Somehow no platitude came, the moment passed and Rocky went down to his own flat.”

The story is essentially told through the medium of conversation, at which Barbara Pym is most skilled. ” ‘Oh, but I think I did know, I mean I guessed,’ I said rather quickly and brightly. ‘I’m so glad.’

‘You’re glad? Oh, what a relief!’ She laughed and lit another cigarette.

‘ Well, it seems a very good thing for both of you and I wish you every happiness,’ I mumbled, not feeling capable of explaining any further a gladness I did not really feel.”

Yes, I did enjoy this free flowing work of a comic novelist very carefully constructed, and not always sad, but the skill of describing the internal and external worlds of the main protagonist leaves me full of empathy for a struggling generation. “Julian waved his brush towards me in a despairing gesture, showering everybody with drops of distemper.”

The author is truly insightful. “Virtue is an excellent thing and we should all strive after it, but it can sometimes be a little depressing.”

A. N. Wilson’s introduction is informative, and

Debra McFarlane’s precisely detailed illustrations are perfectly faithful to the text, to the characters and to the period.

This evening we dined on tasty baked gammon; piquant cauliflower cheese; boiled new potatoes, crunchy carrots and tender chopped cauliflower leaves, with which Jackie drank zesty and I finished the shiraz.

56 comments

  1. I am a Barbara Pym fan and read that novel quite a while ago. I really like to read novels written during the mid-century, especially by women. I am fascinated by the depictions of the changing roles of women.

  2. It must have been heart wrenching for the woman in that time to become widows. So very sad. The illustrations are beautifully drawn!

  3. Barbara Pym is one of my favourite writers. A friend in London is a member of the Barbara Pam Society and a Blue Plaque was unveiled on the house where she was living when her first novel was published. That is a really nice illustrated copy you have,

  4. Love the review and would look forward to reading the book. When I first saw the title, I thought it might be some of the women in your life like your wife, sister, daughter, granddaughter, etc.

  5. That looks a lovely book .. And indeed Derrick the weather has certainly taken on a chillier theme of wind and rain, I had to tie up some plants as they were getting broken back… But I don’t mind the rain so much, as the gardens needed it and it saved us watering the plot 🙂
    Much love your way xx <3

  6. Thanks for the review, Derrick. I’m not familiar with Barbara Pym’s work. That would have been difficult times, indeed. Beautiful illustrations, reminiscent of fashion books of the period.

  7. I think I would like the tone of this book – the internal/external dialogue, the twisted and sometimes self-disparaging humor… Not a book I would likely find without your interesting review. Thank you!

  8. I always enjoy reading your excellent reviews and am pleased to be reminded of Barbara Pym. Your edition is beautifully illustrated too.

  9. A most excellent review of what sounds like an excellent book! 🙂
    And, yes, women ARE excellent! 🙂
    Wow! Those illustrations are amazingly excellent! And are worthy of framing and hanging on a wall to enjoy every day! 🙂
    Thanks for this review, Derrick! 🙂
    (((HUGS))) ❤️❤️

  10. I know of Barbara Pym, but I’m not sure that I’ve ever read any of her books. This does sound very good, and the illustrations are perfect.
    It’s a world I know only from books, TV, and movies.

    1. Thanks very much, Merril. I’m pleased that world is not personally familiar to you

  11. Hi Derrick, another great review. It was hard for many women after WW1 too. My aunt (my biological father was 62 when I was born and he died the same year) lost her fiancé during WW1 ( just like Vera Brittain) so she never married.

  12. I understand “re-reading” perfectly. (Currently re-reading Dorothy Sayers, a generation before that). I shan’t be re-reading Pym, since I haven’t read her to begin with… but I appreciate the subject, (and the illustrations). I don’t think many people still understand those difficult times, and above all the dignity all those wonderful women (and men) had, whilst struggling through very difficult times… They never complained, did they?
    Merci mon cher Derrick.

  13. I yearn to achieve “tight yet eloquent” prose. I get better every day. The illustrations here are beautifully colored and life-like and not the often stylized black and white pen and inks I often see in your reviewed books.

Leave a comment