The Liberal Mind In Victorian England

In this, his next essay in the Folio Society ‘Victorian England’, G.M. Young dwells on the meaning of the word liberal, and how it differs from the wave of liberalism sweeping across Europe “In England, before the French Revolution, it meant magnanimous, open-handed, open-hearted, and….. open-minded, free from prejudice, ready to judge things on their merits.” This mostly concerned the institutions of the Church and the State. Throughout Europe the word was associated with revolution in the search for freedom.

In England this liberalism “…was canalised, so to speak, towards one object, the reform of the House of Commons and an extended franchise. And when that was achieved, and the decision loyally accepted by the Tory opposition, liberalism in England became respectable. If a man called himself a liberal in 1837, no one imagined that he wanted to dethrone the Queen or plunder the bishops. He was certainly a loyal subject and very likely a devout churchman – as Mr Gladstone was….”

The development of science became the English idea of progress which should be incorporated into the best of ancient traditions. This became melded into the “French idea of Liberty, Fraternity, and Equality.” Political freedom and rejection of “everything that may obstruct the progress of industry and the march of the mind…..bringing laws and administration by means of free discussion into accordance with the findings of public opinion….”

“The liberal makes allowance for the fact that the people still respect, admire, and trust the old governing class, so long as it acknowledges the power and final judgement of public opinion.” Still to come would be the establishment of economic equality advocated by the Salvation Army.

This evening we dined on tasty smoked haddock; piquant cauliflower cheese; the chopped cauliflower leaves fried with leeks; and crunchy carrots, with which Jackie drank more of Jessie’s Hoegaarden and I finished Detelina’s Syrah.

25 comments

  1. Interesting to read about the changing definition of liberalism, which of late sure is taking a beating in the United States. Sigh. Never thought of frying cauliflower leaves. Yay to Jackie for using what might be discarded.

  2. Liberalism is very different here and is being used by the Left to try to topple our country. there is a Salvation Army donations store and more that they do, in America.

  3. It’s interesting how the word “liberal” has taken on new meaning over time. I had no idea that the Salvation Army was founded so long ago. Amazing how it has endured. I’ve never heard of cauliflower cheese. Will check it out.

    1. Thank you very much, Rosaliene. The piquancy of the cauliflower cheese is added by a dollop of English mustard

  4. Young’s account is a useful reminder that liberalism was not originally a licence to overturn every inherited convention, but a way of enlarging freedom while remaining within a workable social and political order. Democracy must allow dissent and change, but within reasonable boundaries set by the rights of others, the rule of law and democratic institutions. Such limits are not a decay of democracy; they are part of what keeps it workable.

  5. After reading Equip’s reply, I remembered reading recently that, despite what we see on Prime Minister’s Question Time, many on opposite sides are actually friends behind the scenes.

    1. Thanks very much, Jan. Generally, well, but far less mobile. I now have a disabled parking badge.

Leave a comment