The Political System Under Stress: George III And The Politicians, 1760-1770

This essay, by Geoffrey Holmes and Daniel Szechi, is the sixth in the second part of ‘England in the Eighteenth Century’.

“The political stability of the later 1750s depended on two wasting assets; success in a war which the political nation would inevitably grow weary of and the ageing king’s unflinching support for the Pitt-Newcastle coalition. George II’s death, then, made th onset of a fresh bout of political instability highly likely. The new king’s approach to politics and to his grandfather’s ministers soon precipitated a crisis, but thereafter this crisis rapidly acquired its own momentum.”

These authors focus on the conflict between the Whigs and the Tories and the king’s wavering position between them.

“The root cause of the collapse of the old political order was the removal of the Whig-Tory antagonism that had sustained it for so long…… The key event, therefore was the disappearance of the Tory party.”

What happened was the association of the Tories with the ‘King’s Friends, who he was more likely to follow than his own ministers. Particularly concerning the Seven Years War and the difficulties over taxing the American colonies. The Pitt-Newcastle ministry was never forgiven by George for its betrayal of Prussia. Although this group were persuaded to return afterwards they lost favour and Pitt resigned.

Neither the king nor his ministers appreciated the American colonies’ anger over the Stamp Act and tea duty, which erupted into violence only five weeks into Lord North’s premiership, and led ultimately to the American Revolution or the war of Independence.

My work on this post was interrupted by a splendidly vibrant sunset which sent us off to the coast. I finished it afterwards.

Jackie’s car problem had been resolved by Downton Service Station. The unnecessary plastic cover which was now in four pieces was removed and thrown away by the mechanic who made no charge. She is still without her laptop which as been infected with malicious pop-ups. Peacock Computers are now working on their removal.

The first three sunset pictures were produced from the Royal Oak car park in Downton Lane;

the next three from Milford on Sea;

and the rest from Marine Drive East at Barton on Sea; after which,

from the same coast road, were the windows of the Beachcomber café and a set of Christmas decorations.

This evening we dined on herby lamb’s leg chops; boiled new potatoes and crunchy carrots with tender runner beans; accompanied by the same beverages as yesterday.

Mostly Administration

We now write very few Christmas cards. I prepared a batch today and we posted them from Everton Post Office.

The plastic cover on the underside of the car has now broken into four pieces so Jackie had to take it to Downton Service Station, where they simply removed it and threw it away. This was just as well because she needed her car to take her laptop to Peacock Computers in Lymington because it has been hacked and frozen.

Particularly because of the number of photographs I have been posting recently it is imperative that I get on with my iPhotos culling, beginning with all but one of those featured in

and every one in

and in

This evening we dined on a third helping of Jackie’s lamb’s offal casserole with similar vegetables, having added whole grain mustard to the mashed potatoes. She drank Conde Noble rosé and I drank Beachfront limited edition zinfandel 2022.

Pannage At Ibsley

On a largely overcast afternoon we took a forest drive, and reached Ibsley before we saw anything of note. Then, like buses, lots of pigs hove into view. 2025 has been termed a mast year, which means there has been such a plentiful supply of acorns and such, poisonous to ponies, that pannage has been extended into next year.

Most of the animals were content to bother the traffic around the ford; a smaller, grinning group slaked their thirsts in the winterbourne pond. While I explained pannage to a toddler and his Dad in their car, his Mum crouched photographing the paddlers.

I noticed some mushrooms at the base of a post.

Wet donkeys and ponies are now wearing their winter coats.

Jackie photographed me photographing the pigs and also some of her own.

This is her take on the grey pony from my last gallery.

Elizabeth visited us bringing Christmas presents of which we sent her home with more, after she had joined us for dinner which was a repeat of yesterday’s casserole with fresh vegetables. Jackie and I finished last night’s beverages while my sister drank Brewdog alcohol free beer.

King George III: A Study Of Personality

Published in 1990, this essay, the fifth, by Sir Lewis Namier, in the second section of Roy Porter’s ‘England in the Eighteenth Century’, as its title suggests, deals with the nature of the man, perhaps harshly termed the mad King.

“In the eighteenth century, a proper balance between king, Lords, and Commons, that is, the monarchical, aristocratic, and representative elements of the Constitution acting as checks on each other, was supposed to safeguard the property and privileges, the lives and liberty of the subjects…….. The technique of parliamentary opposition was fully established long before its most essential aim, which is to force a change of government was recognised as legitimate.” George was accused of ruling not through the ministers of his own choice whom he avowed in public, but through a hidden gang of “Obscure and sinister ‘King’s Friends’.”, one of whom was John Stuart, 3rd Earl of Bute, whom the king, before falling out with him, regarded as an important friend and mentor.

Lord Waldegrave, who had been governor to George as the Prince of Wales between 1752 and 1756, wrote in 1758 a ‘penetrating and just’ character sketch, which held firm unchanged over the next 50 years: ‘His parts, though not excellent, will be found very tolerable, if ever they are properly exercised. He is strictly honest, but wants that frank and open behaviour which makes honesty appear amiable…. His religion is free from all hypocrisy, but is not of the most charitable sort; he has rather too much attention to the sins of his neighbour. He has spirit, but not of the active kind; and does not want resolution, but it is mixed with too much obstinacy. He has great command of his passions, and will seldom do wrong, except when he mistakes wrong for right; but as often as this shall happen, it will be difficult to undeceive him, because he is uncommonly indolent, and has strong prejudices. His want of application and aversion to business would be far less dangerous, was he eager in the pursuit of pleasure: for the transition from pleasure to business is both shorter and easier than from a state of total inaction. He has a kind of unhappiness in his temper, which, if it be not conquered before it has taken too deep a root, will be a source of frequent anxiety. Whenever he is displeased, his anger does not break out with heat and violence; but he becomes sullen and silent, and retires to his closet: not to compose his mind by study or contemplation, but merely to enjoy the melancholy enjoyment of his own ill humour. Even when the fit is ended, unfavourable symptoms very frequently return, which indicate that on certain occasions his Royal Highness has to correct a memory.’

Years later “the same high claims on himself, and the same incapacity to meet real situations he was faced with: hence his continued dependence on others”, successively Bute, Cumberland, Pitt, Chatham, and North.

“A great deal of the pattern of George III’s behaviour throughout life can be traced back to his upbringing.” He was given a painful consciousness of his inadequacy….. Excessive demands on a child, complete with wholesome exhortations, are fit to reduce it to a state of hebetude from which it is not easy to recover.”

“He spent his young years cut off from intercourse with boys of his own age, till he himself ceased to desire it….. Isolation by itself would be apt to suggest to a child that there was something wrong with those he had to shun; but this he was probably told I so many words….So the boy spent joyless years in a well-regulated nursery, the nearest approach to a concentration camp: lonely but never alone, constantly watched and discussed, never safe from the wisdom and goodness of the grown-ups; never with anyone on terms of equality, exalted yet oppressed by deferential adults….[he] could not hit back as a child would among children: he could merely retire and nurture his griefs and grievances….”

“I have given here a picture of George III as seen in his letters, ‘warts and all’. What I have never able to find is the man arrogating power to himself, the ambitious schemer out to dominate, the intriguer dealing in an underhand fashion with his ministers; in short, any evidence for the stories circulated about him by very clever and eloquent contemporaries. “…..perhaps it was his deeper kindness, his real piety, and sincere wish to do good…” [that] “… more and more endeared him to the people.”

Namier says [George’s]” insanity was a form of manic depression.”

I prefer what Polly Putnam, curator of Kew Palace, on 22nd March 2024 published in https://www.hrp.org.uk/blog/the-kings-malady-george-iiis-mental-illness-explored/ : “We can never really know what caused George III’s illness, but we do know that the King suffered greatly both physically and mentally.” Accounts differ wildly and can be interpreted in many ways: These inconsistencies have led historians to ‘diagnose’ the King with many different illnesses and conditions including arsenic poisoning, porphyria, and most recently bipolar disorder.”

I recommend Putnam’s article for further reading.

This evening we dined on Jackie’s wholesome lamb’s heart and liver casserole; mashed sweet and white potato; firm carrots; and tender broccoli, with which she drank Vineyards Juicy rosé and I drank more of the merlot.

Wreath Laying Dinner

This morning I read ‘King George III’, an essay by Sir Lewis Namier, but had no time to review it before visiting Robert Alan Jewellers to collect a Christmas present.

We drove on to Shelly and Ron’s home where we joined Helen and Bill. After mulled wine and home-made mince pies the ladies visited their mother’s burial plot to lay their annual wreath, while the husbands stayed largely talking sport.

We then dined on Shelly’s excellent beef casserole; mustard-laced mashed potato; tender broccoli stems and green beans, followed by mixed fruit crumble with custard or cream. Red and white wines were drunk. Needless to say no further sustenance was required after we had arrived home.

At The Crib

On a largely overcast afternoon we took a forest drive, returning at twilight to Milford on Sea green.

Wet ponies at gloomy East End concentrated on cropping wet grass.

Trees everywhere were silhouetted against the moody skies;

and reflected in winterbourne pools.

Along Exbury Road last lingering leaves emulated starlight, as did the

Christmas lights enjoyed by families on Milford’s green

In particular children adored gathering at the crib.

This evening we dined on rack of pork ribs in barbecue sauce; Jackie’s flavoursome vegetable rice; and tender broccoli stems, with which she drank Zesty rosé and I drank Chilean Merlot 2025.

William Pitt, Earl Of Chatham

After lunch, Jackie drove me to Sears Barbers at Milford on Sea where I had my hair cut.

Nick, of Peacock Computers, arrived on time later and quickly fixed our landline problem.

Later I read ‘William Pitt, Earl of Chatham’ by Stanley Ayling; this is the next brief essay in the second section of ‘England in the Eighteenth Century”.

It seems that Pitt was in and out of office as Prime Minister, continually battling with severe illness, either physical or emotional or both. He needed crutches for persistent gout and was periodically crippled with severe depression that some regarded as madness.

He was never so energised as when he was involved in war. He was more interested in wresting Canada from the French than he was in Hanoverian interests in Europe or ousting the Spanish from the West Indies; and was opposed to American independence.

Having resigned in 1761, “….. while George III struggled with the Whig factions, Pitt stayed in the shadows, invalid but still ambitious and redoubtable; aloof, oracular, unpredictable and unbending. He could still compel in the Commons the sort of attention given to no one else so intently,…..” When, however he was urged to return to the king’s service, “…..Pitt’s responses were devious and ambiguous. He was a master of the opaque rigmarole. He mystified and exasperated.” Essentially he was determined to have his own way on all policy, but eventually collapsed while speaking in Parliament and died a few weeks later.

Later, I continued culling my iPhotos file by deleting all the pictures appearing in

but only five of those in

and all in

This evening we dined on Lidl’s de Luxe well-filled chicken Kiev; Jackie’s flavoursome vegetable rice; tender green beans and sugar snap pods, with which we each finished yesterday’s beverages.

Published
Categorised as Books

George II Reconsidered

I spent a very frustrating time on attempting a further telephone conversation with British Gas after the receipt this morning of a letter from their solicitors, Flint Bishop Ltd, on the same lines as all communication since the beginning of October. Our landline isn’t working and we kept being cut off on the mobile.

Eventually I gave up and read ‘George II Reconsidered’.

This essay by John B. Owen is the third in the second section of ‘England in the Eighteenth Century’ by Roy Porter.

Owen focuses on the king’s struggles with his ministers, constantly contrasting him with the first and third Hanoverian rulers of England. “It is general knowledge that, because of his love of Hanover and his tendency to promote its interests in the conduct of foreign policy and war, he enjoyed very little popularity among his British subjects; that he was utterly devoted to, though at times singularly inconsiderate of, his intelligent and politically articulate wife, Queen Caroline; that he had a deep and abiding hatred of his ‘half-witted coxcomb’ of a son, Frederick, Prince of Wales….; that he was the last British monarch to lead an army in the field, his physical courage – unlike his political courage – never being called in question….. But otherwise the second of the Hanoverians remains for the most part a somewhat shadowy and little-considered nonentity.”

“..it is probably fair to argue that most historians have tended to assume – if not state explicitly – that George II was an ineffectual king, and that during his reign a decline in monarchical power that had begun under his father became ever more marked.”

George did not understand politicians or the English Parliamentary system and his reign was fraught with battles between them. With neither his queen, who died early, nor Walpole, who eventually was forced to resign, he did not know how to deal with ministerial conflicts, and continually flouted advice, sometimes going ahead with what he wanted anyway. Sometimes, as in relation to the Bedchamber, the army, episcopal appointments, and parliamentary elections he could insist on his own will.

After this, I deleted those photographs from my iPhotos collection that feature in

and all but one in

and two of those from

This evening we dined on Mr Pink’s perfect fish and chips; Garner’s pickled onions; and Mrs Elswood’s sandwich gherkins, with which Jackie drank Erdinger Weissbier and I drank more of yesterday’s Merlot.

“You Never See A Brown Tree”

The only sound emanating from our car today was that of relentless heavy rain ricocheting from our battered roof as we drove into more persistent precipitation.

As I pointed out a day or so ago our wet weather has brightened the moss coating our forestry. This was even more apparent today.

Not only moss but also lichen and mushrooms were very much in evidence during our trip round the lanes.

Everywhere we looked reminded us of what both Jackie’s teenage art mistress and my art master six years earlier had told us: “You never see a brown tree”, in order to make us look properly at the colouring.

While I focussed on the above gallery Jackie pictured this grey glove becoming soggier by the day.

I then deleted from my iPhotos file all the pictures featured in

Later I read ‘Political Management of Sir Robert Walpole 1720-1742’ by Eveline Cruickshanks, which struggled to retain my interest. I’m not really a fan of political history so this brief essay, the second of those forming the second section of ‘England in the Eighteenth Century did not engage me.

However- “As a person, Walpole was affable and approachable and well liked in Parliament. He was particularly gracious to new MPs, lying in wait ‘in that old spacious court’ (the Court of Requests through which members entered the House), calling each new boy out by name and then offering an invitation to dinner. Without the eloquence of the elder Pitt, who could speak for four hours holding the House enthralled, Walpole was a clear and powerful orator, speaking with ‘warmth and spirit’ but ‘completely without acrimony’ ” “At the heart of Walpole’s political management was his control of patronage, used more systematically and ruthlessly than his predecessors……Not everyone could be satisfied but, generally speaking, he did not make promises, at least to those that mattered, that he did not keep….”

“Walpole was expected not only to manage Parliament but to win the general elections. In modern times politicians win general elections and then take office, but in the eighteenth century politicians were given office and then won the general election.”

“In the reign of George I, the vast majority of the opposition consisted of Tories.” “George I , who hated the Tories for what he regarded as their desertion of Hanover and the allies at the peace of Utrecht, proscribed the whole party from office at the national and local level.” They hoped the proscription would be taken off “… on the accession of George II in 1727. They were disappointed, as George II hated the Tories even more than his father had done.”

Ms Cruickshanks focusses on Walpole’s keeping the balance between the Whigs and the Tories. His losing this capacity was partly due to his disinterest in the processes of enquiries into prison abuses and political scandals including that of the Charitable Corporation involving leading government supporters feathering their own nests at the expense of the poor. This shifted the positions of power and it became apparent that the 1742 election would be lost. Walpole therefore resigned and entered the Upper House.

This evening we dined on a repeat of yesterday’s piri-piri meal with the addition of sugar snap pea pods; Jackie drank Franziskaner Weissbier and I finished my wine of last night.

Clunk, Click

On another day of unrelenting rainfall we took a trip down to the coast at Milford on Sea. This was to be curtailed in somewhat alarming circumstances.

Dog walkers, others, and I, strained against the wind that bent the grass; and the haze lashed the Isle of Wight into oblivion. Jackie produced the last photograph in the trio above, and the following four

including the waves and the hardy photographer on the cliff top.

Shingle was being flung over the sea wall onto the promenade above.

Kite surfers in the hazy distance of the seawall picture were again just visible over Hurst Spit.

Norwegian rocks will reinforce the defences over the next two years.

Now, what brought our trip to an untimely end?

Suddenly a clunking and clicking came from somewhere beneath the car. Neither of us could bend enough to inspect the cause. Neither could we operate the AA system on line. This got a bit stressful.

Eventually Jackie decided to drive home, hoping for the best, and contact the AA. Only to be told she didn’t have an account. This, of course, was on line. We couldn’t phone anyone because the office doesn’t open on Sundays. She therefore battled with the system and managed to create a new account and order a visit.

This came from Mike, who was totally flummoxed but fortunately a very thorough man who did not like to be beaten. After two drives round the block and the removal, in turn, of each wheel, he eventually found a long plastic cover of something on the underside of the vehicle, which had come loose. He administered a temporary fix and advised us to take it to our normal garage for a permanent one.

This evening we dined on piri-piri chicken and Jackie’s colourful savoury rice, with which we drank the same beverages as yesterday.