On 6th November Robbie Cheadle posted such an inspirational review of this novel by Erich Maria Remarque that I was prompted to reread the iconic work for the first time for almost 60 years.
You may care to read Robbie’s excellent analysis either before or after this review of mine.


Here are the boards and Title page and frontispiece of my Folio Society edition of 1966.
Although well able to provide excellent descriptive narrative and employ literary devices such as metaphor and simile, (“…but if he says it here the sentences have the sharpness of a bayonet in the moonlight”) Remarque largely makes use of the short sentence and the journalistic dramatic or narrative present to emphasise the immediacy of the story and maintain the fast pace of the life and death of the World War I German soldier, contrasted with the slow-moving apparent absence of life on leave or otherwise away from the front. “These are wonderfully carefree hours. Over us is the blue sky. On the horizon float the bright yellow, sunlit observation-balloons, and the many little white clouds of the anti-aircraft shells. Often they rise in a sheaf as they follow after an airman. We hear the muffled rumble of the front only as a very distant thunder, bumble-bees droning by quite drown it. Around us stretches the flowery meadow. The grasses sway their tall spears; the white butterflies flutter around and float on the soft warm wind of the late summer…..” “No-one had the vaguest idea what we were in for.” “To me the front is a mysterious whirlpool. Though I am in still water far away from its centre, I feel the whirl of the vortex sucking me slowly, irresistibly, inescapably, into itself.”
“The air becomes acrid with the smoke of the guns and the fog. The fumes of powder taste bitter on the tongue. The roar of the guns makes our lorry stagger, the reverberation rolls raging away to the rear, everything quakes. Our faces change imperceptibly. We are not, indeed, in the front line, but only in the reserves, yet every face can be read: This is the front, now we are within its embrace.” All senses are engaged, especially that of hearing. Sound, including its absence, conveys important information. “The dull thud of the gas shells mingles with the crashes of the high explosives”; “…. he has his mouth wide open and is yelling. I hear nothing.”
We learn how war changes people; how weak, insignificant, men can become martinets when given authority; how men reliant on each other for survival become “closer than lovers”; how necessity produces generosity towards previously unknown men – even enemies, now prisoners of war. There is an understanding between and empathy for soldiers fighting on opposite sides. “…. just you consider, almost all of us are simple folk. And in France, too, the majority of men are labourers, workmen, or poor clerks. Now just why would a French blacksmith or a French shoemaker want to attack us? No, it is merely the rulers. I had never seen a Frenchman before I came here, and it will be just the same with the majority of Frenchmen as regards us. They weren’t asked about it any more than we were.”
The author doesn’t flinch from describing the grisly reality. “…if a mortar gets you it blows you clean out of your clothes……” “I search around. And so it is. Here hang bits of uniform, and somewhere else is plastered a bloody mess that was once a human limb. Over there lies a body with nothing but a piece of the underpants on one leg and the collar of the tunic around its neck. Otherwise it is naked and the clothes are hanging up in the tree. Both arms are missing as though they had been pulled out. I discover one of them twenty yards off in a shrub.”
“Like an emptying tube, after a couple of minutes he collapses. What use is it to him now that he was such a good mathematician at school.”
The frequency and rapidity of death in hospital, where months of treatment can be followed by a return to the front is equally shocking.
This was meant to be the war to end all wars. It was not to be, and in our time of vastly more methods of destruction where those who send long range missiles never have to see the civilians they are smashing to pieces, and old men are still sending young ones off to die, inhumanity remains rife.
Not knowing any German I can only assume that the translation by A. W. Wheen is accurate. It certainly reads well enough.
In my view the Folio Society could not have found a more suitable illustrator than Charles Keeping for conveying the nature of this work.
Each of the lithographs in this set bears a description of the scene illustrated in the gallery











You chose superb quotes to illustrate your points. Can’t help thinking how Putin’s shift from frontal assaults to drone warfare is sparing his soldiers ( whether Russian or Korean) but not the Ukrainian civilians.
Quite so, Pat. Thank you very much
The descriptions of war and the casualties are so haunting. How anyone can see ‘glory’ in war is beyond me. It seems like we never learn the lesson from the past.
Exactly. Thanks very much, Carol
As always, the lithographs are excellent.
hank you so much, Sue
Excellent review, Derrick. A powerful story. I read this book two years ago on the recommendation of another blogger.
Thank you very much, Rosaliene
The illustrations are as horrific as the descriptions. Some of Keepings’ faces remind me so much of a well-known painting, but I can’t for the life of me remember the title or the artist. The face is rendered all in black with slashing brushstrokes.
Thanks very much, Liz. I can’t think of the painting
You’re welcome, Derrick.
Have you seen Alys’s comment?
Yes, I have. The image I’m thinking of isn’t “The Scream.” It’s rendered in black on a light brown background.
I thought it wouldn’t be.
The Scream?
Of course – The Scream – but I have only seen it in colour
No, not “The Scream.” The one I’m thinking of is done in black on a light brown background.
I have seen several film adaptations over the years but read the book for the first time a few months ago.
It’s very moving and gives an honest picture of the hell of being in the trenches on the front line in the First World War.
I really enjoyed the book, but so tragic.
Thank you very much, Tony
The edition I read many, many years ago had the same impactful illustrations. I’ve seen it in film since also. The story, once read, never leaves you.
I attended a nonfiction writers festival this weekend. One of the sessions was on Fascism. I bought, “Repeat: A Warning from History” by Dennis Glover, which “brings the subject into the modern day, and draws our attention to the perils of populists, dictators and authoritarianism.” I have made a small start. It clearly links WW1 to the rise of Hitler, via the onerous reparations placed on Germany after the Armistice. It will get to Trump 🙂
Thanks very much, Gwen
War is a horrific subject to write about, but your review eloquently outlines the book’s contents, Derrick …
Thank you very much, Ivor
Thank you for sharing your review and for directing us to Robbie’s take on the book as well.
All Quiet on the Western Front was assigned reading when I was a freshman in high school. I remember sitting on the floor after dinner with my back pressed to the furnace in our living room coming to the final pages. It was the first time I burst in to tears at the end of a book. I was shocked, embarrassed, and amazed that it had that effect. I would have been 14 or 15 at the time. You’ve given me a lot to think about once again. My memories are vivid and profound.
Thank you so very much, Alys. The ending was so powerful and you are such a caring person I am not surprised it has that effect – especially at that age
The colours around the streams are subtle and varied at the same time, just beautiful.
Thank you very much, Sylvie
Excellent review!
I first read this book when I was a teenager (it was assigned reading in school). It has always been filled with emotions for me. And, wow, those illustrations are emotion-filled, too.
(((HUGS))) ❤️❤️
Thank you so much, Carolyn XX
I have always enjoyed Charles Keeping’s illustrations – and have enjoyed reading your review of this novel I am very familiar with!
Thanks very much, Anne. I had hoped you would like it
thank you Derrick… revealing
Much appreciated, Q
Well. Thank you, Derrick. Your review is excellent and enticing! Robbie’s had a indescribable quality; a combination of the exuberance of a lover of literature and great story-telling tinged with the sadness and confusion of a mom and a lover of humanity. Thank you for sharing. ~Ed.
An excellent review, and eloquently written, Derrick. I am impressed by your paragraph, and it seems humanity continues to wallow in upheaval.
“This was meant to be the war to end all wars. It was not to be, and in our time of vastly more methods of destruction where those who send long range missiles never have to see the civilians they are smashing to pieces, and old men are still sending young ones off to die, inhumanity remains rife.”
Hi Derrick, you have certainly chosen your quotes for this review well. They make your discussion very impactful. There were no illustrations in the book I read but I can remember exactly which scenes these illustrations belong to. This is not a book you forget. Thank you for sharing the link to my review. It is appreciated.
My pleasure to be sharing with you, Robbie. Many thanks
💜
🤗💞
Looks a haunting and sobering book, as it should be
Thanks very much, Gary
Disturbing illustrations – very fitting.
Thank you so much, Sheree
The translation is very good, and the illustrations are quite impressive.
Thank you very much, Dolly
You are very welcome, Derrick.
An excellent review, Derrick, and the basic concepts still unfortunately applicable to today. Mankind does not change much.
Quie so, Lavinia. Thank you very much